Lieberman A N, Gopinathan G, Neophytides A, Leibowitz M, Walker R, Hiesiger E
Ann Neurol. 1983 Jan;13(1):44-7. doi: 10.1002/ana.410130110.
Lisuride was compared with bromocriptine in 25 parkinsonian patients in whom the response to levodopa had diminished; 19 had "wearing off," "on-off" phenomena, or both. At the time bromocriptine was added to levodopa, the mean age of the patients was 62.7 years and mean disease duration was 8.9 years. Disability decreased by 34% in the on period and by 20% in the off period, and the number of hours the patients were on increased from 9.6 to 12.8. All these changes were significant (p less than or equal to 0.01 to 0.05). Bromocriptine, however, had to be discontinued in 11 patients because of adverse effects. In the remaining 14 patients, bromocriptine was eventually discontinued because of decreased efficacy. Mean dose of bromocriptine was 55 mg (range, 20 to 100 mg). At the time lisuride was added to levodopa the patients were older (65.4 years), had had the disease longer (11.4 years), and were more disabled. Nonetheless, disability decreased in the on period by 33% and in the off period by 17%, and the number of hours the patients were on increased from 3.9 to 8.9. All these changes were significant (p less than or equal to 0.01 to 0.05). The mean dose of lisuride was 2.8 mg (range, 0.6 to 5.0 mg). Lisuride was discontinued in 8 patients because of adverse effects. Both bromocriptine and lisuride are useful in managing patients with advanced Parkinson disease whose response to levodopa has diminished. While it is presently not possible to state which of the drugs is more effective, ultimately their usage will probably be determined by their relative cost.
在25例对左旋多巴反应减退的帕金森病患者中,对利苏瑞得和溴隐亭进行了比较;其中19例有“疗效减退”“开-关”现象或两者皆有。在将溴隐亭加用至左旋多巴治疗时,患者的平均年龄为62.7岁,平均病程为8.9年。在“开”期残疾程度降低了34%,“关”期降低了20%,患者处于“开”期的时长从9.6小时增加至12.8小时。所有这些变化均具有显著性(P≤0.01至0.05)。然而,有11例患者因不良反应而停用溴隐亭。在其余14例患者中,溴隐亭最终因疗效降低而停用。溴隐亭的平均剂量为55毫克(范围为20至100毫克)。在将利苏瑞得加用至左旋多巴治疗时,患者年龄更大(65.4岁),病程更长(11.4年),残疾程度也更高。尽管如此,“开”期残疾程度降低了33%,“关”期降低了17%,患者处于“开”期的时长从3.9小时增加至8.9小时。所有这些变化均具有显著性(P≤0.01至0.05)。利苏瑞得的平均剂量为2.8毫克(范围为0.6至5.0毫克)。有8例患者因不良反应而停用利苏瑞得。溴隐亭和利苏瑞得在治疗对左旋多巴反应减退的晚期帕金森病患者方面均有用。虽然目前尚无法说明哪种药物更有效,但最终它们的使用可能将由其相对成本决定。