Savard R, Bouchard C, Leblanc C, Tremblay A
Ann Hum Biol. 1983 Mar-Apr;10(2):111-8. doi: 10.1080/03014468300006251.
Family resemblance in fatness has been studied in 481 individuals from 114 families of French descent living in the greater Quebec city area. Subjects were measured for the following fatness indicators: triceps, biceps, subscapular, suprailiac, abdominal and medial calf skinfolds. The sum of these six skinfolds as well as a prediction of percent body fat (Durnin and Rahaman 1967) were also considered. Data were standardized for appropriate age and sex classes yielding SS scores. The influence of relevant lifestyle variables (energy intake, energy expenditure and socioeconomic status) were statistically removed from SS yeilding residual scores (RS) that were then submitted to familial analyses. Analyses of variance indicate that there is a larger between family variation than within (P less than or equal to 0.01) for SS when considering either the whole nuclear family or sibships; in these instances, the intra-class correlation ranges from 0.15 to 0.26. There was, however, no significant resemblance among spouses for the SS fatness indicators. Similar values were essentially found for RS fatness indicators. Furthermore, husband-wife inter-class correlations were not significant with the exception of subscapular and calf skinfold RS. Covariations between biological relatives are however significant (0.16 less than or equal to r less than or equal to 0.24, P less than or equal to 0.01) for SS and remain essentially unchanged after statistical control over the lifestyle variables (0.16 less than or equal to r less than or equal to 0.40, P less than or equal to 0.01). The findings that spouses do not covary significantly in fatness, while biological relatives of traditional nuclear families exhibit a significant degree of resemblance even after statistical control over daily energy intake, daily energy expenditure and socioeconomic status provide evidence supporting the hypothesis that there is a substantial genetic effect in human fatness.
对居住在大魁北克市地区的114个法裔家庭的481名个体进行了肥胖家族相似性研究。测量了受试者的以下肥胖指标:肱三头肌、肱二头肌、肩胛下、髂上、腹部和小腿内侧皮褶厚度。还考虑了这六个皮褶厚度之和以及身体脂肪百分比预测值(杜宁和拉哈曼,1967年)。数据根据适当的年龄和性别类别进行标准化,得出SS分数。从SS分数中通过统计方法去除相关生活方式变量(能量摄入、能量消耗和社会经济地位)的影响,得到残差分数(RS),然后对其进行家族分析。方差分析表明,无论是考虑整个核心家庭还是同胞关系,SS分数的家庭间差异都大于家庭内差异(P小于或等于0.01);在这些情况下,组内相关系数范围为0.15至0.26。然而,对于SS肥胖指标,配偶之间没有显著的相似性。RS肥胖指标也基本得到类似的值。此外,除了肩胛下和小腿皮褶RS外,夫妻间的组间相关系数不显著。然而,对于SS分数,生物学亲属之间的协变量是显著的(0.16小于或等于r小于或等于0.24,P小于或等于0.01),并且在对生活方式变量进行统计控制后基本保持不变(0.16小于或等于r小于或等于0.40,P小于或等于0.01)。配偶在肥胖方面没有显著的协变量,而传统核心家庭的生物学亲属即使在对每日能量摄入、每日能量消耗和社会经济地位进行统计控制后仍表现出显著程度的相似性,这些发现为人类肥胖存在显著遗传效应这一假设提供了证据支持。