Louhimo I, Lindahl H
J Pediatr Surg. 1983 Jun;18(3):217-29. doi: 10.1016/s0022-3468(83)80089-x.
During 1947-1978, 500 patients with esophageal atresia and/or tracheoesophageal fistula were treated at the Children's Hospital, University of Helsinki. The proportion of different types of anomaly followed the usual distribution, the commonest being the type with distal fistula (88.2%). For analysis, the patients were divided into five phases, each consisting of 100 consecutively treated patients. The hospital mortality decreased from 81% in the first phase to 15% in the last phase. No patients were excluded, not even those cases with lethal associated anomalies. Many more severe cases were treated in the last two phases than in the first three. Patients with distal fistula were examined separately as were the patients without a fistula and those with only a tracheoesophageal fistula. With time, early diagnosis and early referral for treatment became a rule. This led to the policy that nearly all patients in the last phase had an early operation without staging. Gastrostomy was not considered necessary when early anastomosis was possible. In the last phase, only the transpleural approach was used and single-layer end-to-end anastomosis was favored. As a whole, the type of approach or anastomosis did not have significant effect on the results, except that the Sulamaa-type end-to-side anastomosis had the highest frequency for refistula. With time there was only a slight decrease in the incidence of anastomotic leak, but significant improvement in its management. Refistula as an early complication was seen only once in the last phase. As all anastomoses were routinely dilated, severe strictures were uncommon; there were only six in the series. The factor that probably improved the prognosis the most was better pulmonary care. The improved prognosis was also due to earlier referral, modern anesthesia, and intensive care. Postoperative pulmonary complications dropped from 92% in the first phase to 40% in the last. They were the most common single cause of death in the early series but caused no deaths among the last 100 patients with no associated anomalies. Low birth weight was an important prognostic factor early in the series but in the last phase the survival rate of under-2500-gm infants with no associated anomalies was 88%. The presence of severe associated anomalies remains the most important single cause of death of an esophageal atresia patient today. Some patients (eg, trisomy 18) are beyond the possibilities of surgical treatment. To improve the prognosis of the others, efforts in the treatment of their associated (especially cardiovascular) anomalies must be made. In the treatment of esophageal atresia itself, improvement may still be achieved in the number of patients using their own esophagus without replacement procedures. Finally, a new prognostic classification of esophageal atresia patients is suggested, excluding pneumonia as an index factor in the Waterston classification.
1947年至1978年间,赫尔辛基大学儿童医院收治了500例食管闭锁和/或气管食管瘘患者。不同类型畸形的比例符合常见分布,最常见的是伴有远端瘘的类型(88.2%)。为进行分析,将患者分为五个阶段,每个阶段由100例连续接受治疗的患者组成。医院死亡率从第一阶段的81%降至最后阶段的15%。没有患者被排除,即使是伴有致命相关畸形的病例也未被排除。与前三阶段相比,后两阶段治疗的重症病例更多。伴有远端瘘的患者、无瘘患者以及仅有气管食管瘘的患者分别进行了检查。随着时间的推移,早期诊断和早期转诊治疗成为常态。这导致了一项政策,即最后阶段几乎所有患者都进行了早期手术,无需分期。如果可以早期进行吻合术,则认为无需进行胃造口术。在最后阶段,仅采用经胸入路,且倾向于单层端端吻合术。总体而言,手术入路或吻合方式对结果没有显著影响,只是苏拉马亚型端侧吻合术的再瘘发生率最高。随着时间的推移,吻合口漏的发生率仅略有下降,但其处理有了显著改善。再瘘作为早期并发症仅在最后阶段出现过一次。由于所有吻合口都常规进行扩张,严重狭窄并不常见;该系列中仅有6例。可能对预后改善最大的因素是更好的肺部护理。预后的改善还得益于更早的转诊、现代麻醉和重症监护。术后肺部并发症从第一阶段的92%降至最后阶段的40%。它们是早期系列中最常见的单一死亡原因,但在最后100例无相关畸形的患者中未导致死亡。低出生体重在该系列早期是一个重要的预后因素,但在最后阶段,体重不足2500克且无相关畸形的婴儿的存活率为88%。严重相关畸形的存在至今仍是食管闭锁患者最重要的单一死亡原因。一些患者(如18三体综合征患者)无法进行手术治疗。为改善其他患者的预后,必须努力治疗他们的相关(尤其是心血管)畸形。在食管闭锁本身的治疗方面,在不采用替代手术的情况下使用自身食管的患者数量仍有可能进一步增加。最后,建议对食管闭锁患者进行一种新的预后分类,将肺炎排除在沃斯顿分类的指标因素之外。