Kelly J F
J Dent Educ. 1981 Apr;45(4):222-35.
This paper identifies issues, develops alternatives, and analyzes and evaluates the impact of trends and predicted changes in health care and health care financing; compares graduate dental education with nonprofessional and professional (especially medical) graduate education; and concludes there are greater similarities than differences in the financing of education in the academic disciplines and the professions. Two generalizations are drawn from this comparison: (1) practical experience under supervision precedes practice, and (2) the student pays for education solely for his or her benefit. Students are remunerated for productive work in lieu of compensated staff. This discussion identifies a distinction between medical and dental education that influences graduate dental education. In medicine, the prevailing practice in the clinical years is for students to observe care of patients provided by qualified physicians, in dentistry, prevailing practice is for students to provide care under the supervision of qualified dentists. A comparison of clinical training in medicine and dentistry discloses the following.
本文识别了一些问题,提出了替代方案,并分析和评估了医疗保健及医疗保健融资领域的趋势和预测变化所产生的影响;将牙科研究生教育与非专业和专业(尤其是医学)研究生教育进行了比较;并得出结论,学术学科和专业领域在教育融资方面的相似之处多于差异。从这一比较中得出了两个一般性结论:(1)在监督下的实践经验先于实际执业,(2)学生只为自身利益支付教育费用。学生通过从事生产性工作获得报酬,以替代有薪酬的工作人员。本讨论确定了医学教育与牙科教育之间的一个区别,该区别影响着牙科研究生教育。在医学领域,临床阶段的普遍做法是学生观察合格医生对患者的治疗,而在牙科领域,普遍做法是学生在合格牙医的监督下提供治疗。对医学和牙科临床培训的比较揭示了以下情况。