Lee M M, Wight A J, Stanmeyer W R
J Dent Educ. 1981 Jun;45(6):344-8.
A study was undertaken to test the hypothesis that self-instructional programs in nutrition and dentistry are as effective a teaching method as traditional lectures. Five programmed self-instructional manuals accompanied by 191 slides were developed and evaluated for effectiveness, as compared to six lectures containing the same information. The study population of 83 freshmen dental students was randomly assigned to a control (lecture) group and an experimental (self-instruction) group. Cognitive tests, performance criteria for diet counseling, and an attitudinal questionnaire were used to compare the two groups. The results of the analysis demonstrated that there was no significant difference in the test scores in the lecture and self-instruction groups.
开展了一项研究,以检验营养与牙科方面的自我指导课程与传统讲座具有同样有效教学方法这一假设。与包含相同信息的六场讲座相比,开发了五本配有191张幻灯片的自我指导手册并对其有效性进行评估。83名牙科专业新生的研究群体被随机分配到对照组(讲座组)和实验组(自我指导组)。使用认知测试、饮食咨询的表现标准和一份态度调查问卷来比较两组。分析结果表明,讲座组和自我指导组的测试成绩没有显著差异。