Lowe G P, McNeur J C
Aust N Z J Surg. 1981 Dec;51(6):528-33. doi: 10.1111/j.1445-2197.1981.tb05247.x.
The Geometric Total Knee Arthroplasty was one of the earliest unconstrained knee arthroplasties available for the replacement of knees severely affected by destructive arthritis. This paper presents the results of Geometric knee arthroplasty performed by surgeons of the Alfred Hospital, Melbourne, during the years 1973 to 1977, this being the initial five years experience with this procedure. One hundred and fifty arthroplasty operations were performed in 106 patients, 78 for osteoarthritis and 72 for rheumatoid arthritis, with the average time from operation to review being four years. The Geometric arthroplasty was used in 147 of these operations. Assessment was based on a modification of the British Orthopaedic Association Knee Function Assessment Chart (1978) and 137 knees were available for review. Eighty nine percent of patients suffering osteoarthritis, and 79% of patients with rheumatoid arthritis were satisfied or enthusiastic with their prosthesis. Nineteen percent of rheumatoid patients and 4% of osteoarthritic patients considered the result of their operation disappointing. In both groups, the operated knee constituted minimal persisting disability to the patient when reviewed. Seventeen knees (11.3%) were assessed as unsatisfactory, of which 7 (4.6%) were due to infection, and 5 (3.3%) were due to loosening. Revision procedures were performed in 7 knees (5%), for instability or loosening. Improvements in arthroplasty design have resulted in alternative prostheses now being chosen by most surgeons for knee replacement, and the long term results of these newer prostheses must be evaluated with those results obtained using the original geometric prosthesis.
几何型全膝关节置换术是最早用于置换受破坏性关节炎严重影响的膝关节的非限制性膝关节置换术之一。本文介绍了墨尔本阿尔弗雷德医院的外科医生在1973年至1977年期间进行的几何型膝关节置换术的结果,这是该手术最初五年的经验。106例患者共进行了150例置换手术,其中78例为骨关节炎,72例为类风湿性关节炎,从手术到复查的平均时间为四年。其中147例手术使用了几何型置换术。评估基于对英国骨科协会膝关节功能评估表(1978年)的修改,137例膝关节可供复查。89%的骨关节炎患者和79%的类风湿性关节炎患者对其假体感到满意或满意程度很高。19%的类风湿性关节炎患者和4%的骨关节炎患者认为手术结果令人失望。在两组患者复查时,手术膝关节给患者造成的持续残疾最小。17例膝关节(11.3%)被评估为不满意,其中7例(4.6%)是由于感染,5例(3.3%)是由于松动。7例膝关节(5%)因不稳定或松动进行了翻修手术。关节置换术设计的改进导致现在大多数外科医生选择其他假体进行膝关节置换,这些新型假体的长期结果必须与使用原始几何型假体获得的结果进行评估。