Brolin R E, Stremple J F
Am Surg. 1982 Jul;48(7):302-8.
From January 1973 through December 1977, 580 patients presented with 624 episodes of upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage at the University fo Pittsburgh Health Center Hospitals. Ninety-one patients (15%) underwent operation for uncontrollable hemorrhage. Operative mortality was 30 per cent for all patients and 21 per cent for patients with gastroduodenal bleeding (duodenal ulcer, gastric ulcer, erosive gastritis). In patients with gastroduodenal bleeding, seven of 15(47%) with preoperative hypotensive shock (systolic b.p. less than or equal to .02). Twenty-five patients had vagotomy and pyloroplasty with suture ligation of bleeding ulcers, while 34 patients underwent gastric resection. The operative mortality for resection was 21 per cent (7/34) compared with 16 percent (4/25) for vagotomy and pyloroplasty. The incidence of rebleeding was 15 per cent (5/34) for resection and 8 per cent (2/25 for vagotomy and pyloroplasty. Nine patients (26%) has suture-line leaks following resection, and none were found after vagotomy and pyloroplasty. Severe of nine patients (78%) who had leaks after resection had hypotensive shock prior to operation. Six of the seven patients who died following gastric resection had complication (either leak or rebleeding) directly related to the operative procedure, while the four deaths following vagotomy and pyloroplasty occurred in patients not having procedure-related complications. Procedure-related morbidity (leaks and rebleeding) with resection (41%) was significantly higher than with vagotomy and pyloroplasty (8%) (P less than or equal to .01). These data show vagotomy and pyloroplasty to be the safer operation for patients with uncontrollable gastroduodenal hemorrhage, particularly those with preoperative hypotension.
1973年1月至1977年12月期间,580例患者在匹兹堡大学健康中心医院出现624次上消化道出血发作。91例患者(15%)因出血无法控制而接受手术。所有患者的手术死亡率为30%,胃十二指肠出血患者(十二指肠溃疡、胃溃疡、糜烂性胃炎)的手术死亡率为21%。在胃十二指肠出血患者中,15例术前有低血压休克(收缩压小于或等于90mmHg)的患者中有7例(47%)死亡。25例患者接受了迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术并缝合结扎出血性溃疡,而34例患者接受了胃切除术。胃切除术的手术死亡率为21%(7/34),而迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术的手术死亡率为16%(4/25)。胃切除术的再出血发生率为15%(5/34),迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术的再出血发生率为8%(2/25)。9例患者(26%)在胃切除术后出现缝合线漏,迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术后未发现缝合线漏。胃切除术后出现漏的9例患者中有7例(78%)在术前有低血压休克。胃切除术后死亡的7例患者中有6例出现与手术操作直接相关的并发症(漏或再出血),而迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术后死亡的4例患者未出现与手术相关的并发症。胃切除术相关的发病率(漏和再出血)为41%,明显高于迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术(8%)(P小于或等于0.01)。这些数据表明,对于无法控制的胃十二指肠出血患者,尤其是术前有低血压的患者,迷走神经切断术和幽门成形术是更安全的手术。