Welsh P W, Zimmermann E M, Yunginger J W, Kern E B, Gleich G J
J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1981 Mar;67(3):237-42. doi: 10.1016/0091-6749(81)90067-1.
We determined the effect of preseasonal intranasal short ragweed (SRW) immunotherapy in a double-blind, nonpaired, 20-wk study involving 33 SRW-sensitive patients. Patients were selected on the basis of an elevated IGE serum antibody level, a positive intradermal skin test, and a positive intranasal challenge to SRW antigen. SRW-treated patients sprayed SRW solutions intranasally six times a day for 12 wk preseasonally. Placebo-treated patients used nebulized solutions containing buffer or histamine that were interchanged randomly throughout this period. The SRW-treated group reported more preseasonal symptoms than the placebo-treated group (p less than 0.003); however, during the SRW pollination season, the SRW-treated group reported significantly less sneezing, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, red/itchy eyes, itchy nose/throat, and cough/wheeze. Supplemental antihistamine usage was similar in both groups. The treatment did not affect serum IgE antibody levels to crude SRW, AgE Ra3, or Ra5 in either group at any time during the study. No significant production of IgG antibody to SRW was seen in either group. One SRW-treated patient developed acute sinusitis after 2 wk of treatment; otherwise no side effects other than symptoms of hay fever were noted. Although intranasal SRW immunotherapy may offer an effective and less costly alternative to parenteral immunotherapy, reduction in hay fever symptoms during the pollination season was achieved at the expense of provoking these symptoms during the preceding weeks.
我们在一项涉及33名对短豚草(SRW)敏感患者的双盲、非配对、为期20周的研究中,确定了季前鼻内短豚草免疫疗法的效果。患者根据血清IgE抗体水平升高、皮内皮肤试验阳性以及对SRW抗原的鼻内激发试验阳性来选择。接受SRW治疗的患者在季前每天鼻内喷洒SRW溶液6次,持续12周。接受安慰剂治疗的患者使用含有缓冲液或组胺的雾化溶液,在此期间随机交替使用。接受SRW治疗的组报告的季前症状比接受安慰剂治疗的组更多(p小于0.003);然而,在SRW授粉季节,接受SRW治疗的组报告的打喷嚏、鼻塞、流涕、眼睛发红/瘙痒、鼻子/喉咙瘙痒以及咳嗽/喘息明显更少。两组补充抗组胺药的使用情况相似。在研究期间的任何时候,该治疗对两组患者针对粗制SRW、AgE Ra3或Ra5的血清IgE抗体水平均无影响。两组均未观察到针对SRW的IgG抗体有显著产生。一名接受SRW治疗的患者在治疗2周后发生了急性鼻窦炎;除此之外,除了花粉热症状外未观察到其他副作用。尽管鼻内SRW免疫疗法可能为肠胃外免疫疗法提供一种有效且成本较低的替代方法,但授粉季节花粉热症状的减轻是以在前几周引发这些症状为代价的。