Filo R S, Smith E J, Leapman S B
Transplantation. 1980 Dec;30(6):445-9. doi: 10.1097/00007890-198012000-00012.
A randomized and controlled study was conducted to evaluate the efficacy of adjunctive antithymocyte globulin (ATG) therapy for the treatment of the initial rejection episode in first cadaveric transplants. When compared to the control group (29), which received only standard antirejection treatment (SAT) of steroid pulsing and local irradiation, the adjunctive ATG treatment group (23) demonstrated significantly faster recovery rates (8.9 +/- 4.1 versus 6.9 +/- 3.7 days, P = 0.05, respectively) and better graft survival rates (62 +/- 9% versus 91 +/- 7%, respectively) after the first rejection. ATG treatment did not result in fewer subsequent rejection episodes than SAT but long-term allograft survival rates remained superior to controls for the entire 3-year study period. By avoiding ATG treatment in those patients who never experienced clinical rejection on maintenance immunosuppressive therapy, i.e., nonresponders (23 of 90), complications associated with excessive immunosuppression were minimized. The combined results of the non-responder group of patients and ATG-treated patients resulted in a 1-year patient survival of 97% and graft survival of 86%. These results suggest that the most efficacious use of ATG is therapeutic and not prophylactic in renal transplant patients.
开展了一项随机对照研究,以评估辅助性抗胸腺细胞球蛋白(ATG)疗法在治疗首例尸体肾移植初次排斥反应中的疗效。与仅接受类固醇冲击和局部照射的标准抗排斥治疗(SAT)的对照组(29例)相比,辅助性ATG治疗组(23例)在首次排斥反应后显示出明显更快的恢复速度(分别为8.9±4.1天和6.9±3.7天,P = 0.05)以及更高的移植物存活率(分别为62±9%和91±7%)。ATG治疗并未使随后的排斥反应发作次数少于SAT,但在整个3年研究期内,长期同种异体移植物存活率仍高于对照组。通过在维持免疫抑制治疗中从未经历临床排斥反应的患者(即无反应者,90例中的23例)中避免使用ATG治疗,与过度免疫抑制相关的并发症降至最低。无反应者组患者和接受ATG治疗患者的综合结果显示,1年患者存活率为97%,移植物存活率为86%。这些结果表明,在肾移植患者中,ATG最有效的用途是治疗性而非预防性。