Bacal E, Zeiss C R, Suszko I, Levitz D, Patterson R
J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1978 Nov;62(5):288-94. doi: 10.1016/0091-6749(78)90160-4.
A single-blind study compared the effectiveness of glutaraldehyde-treated polymerized ragweed with nonpolymerized monomeric ragweed. These studies are an extension of those previously reported for polymerized AgE using a readily available ragweed preparation containing all ragweed antigens. Nineteen ragweed-sensitive patients were randomized into 2 groups; 10 received the polymerized form and 9 received the monomeric form. Four parameters were followed: serum-specific IgE against antigen E, total blocking antibody against antigen E, local and systemic reactions to injection therapy, and symptom score indices. Pretreatment levels of antigen E--specific IgE and blocking antibody activity were similar in both groups. After a total of 15,000 protein nitrogen units (PNU) had been given, blocking antibody activity in the monomer group rose from a mean of 170 ng AgE bound per ml to a mean of 2,813. The rise in blocking antibody activity in the polymer group was from a mean of 181 ng AgE bound per ml to 1,574. At 15,000 PNU, blocking antibody activity levels were not statistically different in the 2 groups. After 1 year of treatment, no consistent decrease in postseasonal specific IgE rise could be shown in either group. Forty times less erythema and 15 times less induration were found with polymerized ragweed. There were 7 systemic reactions with the monomer and none with the polymer. Both groups experienced symptomatic improvement with treatment.
一项单盲研究比较了戊二醛处理的聚合豚草与未聚合的单体豚草的有效性。这些研究是先前报道的使用含有所有豚草抗原的现成豚草制剂对聚合变应原提取物(AgE)研究的扩展。19名豚草敏感患者被随机分为两组;10人接受聚合形式,9人接受单体形式。跟踪了四个参数:针对抗原E的血清特异性IgE、针对抗原E的总阻断抗体、注射治疗的局部和全身反应以及症状评分指数。两组中抗原E特异性IgE和阻断抗体活性的预处理水平相似。在总共给予15000蛋白氮单位(PNU)后,单体组的阻断抗体活性从每毫升平均结合170 ng AgE升至平均2813 ng AgE。聚合组中阻断抗体活性从每毫升平均结合181 ng AgE升至1574 ng AgE。在15000 PNU时,两组的阻断抗体活性水平无统计学差异。治疗1年后,两组均未显示出季节性特异性IgE升高的持续下降。聚合豚草引起的红斑减少40倍,硬结减少15倍。单体组出现7次全身反应,聚合组未出现全身反应。两组治疗后症状均有改善。