Kelsen D, Gralla R, Stoopler M, Casper E, Cheng E, Kosloff C, Golbey R
Cancer Treat Rep. 1982 Feb;66(2):247-51.
Seventy-four patients with non-small cell lung cancer were treated in a prospective, randomized trial either with a four-drug combination of cisplatin, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, and vindesine (PACE) or with a three-drug combination of cisplatin, cyclophosphamide, and vindesine (PCE). None of these patients had received prior chemotherapy, and all had a Karnofsky performance status of at least 60. Of 68 evaluable patients, 21 (31%) had complete or partial remissions. Response rates for PACE and PCE were similar, and there was no difference in response rates for patients with adenocarcinoma or epidermoid cancer. The median duration of remission was 10 months (range, 2-26+); five patients are still in remission (median, 18+ months; range, 17+ to 26+). The median duration of survival for responding patients (complete or partial) was 18 months. Toxic effects, including mild to moderate myelosuppression, peripheral neuropathy, and nephrotoxicity, were manageable in general. The response rates and remission durations for PACE and PCE are similar to those seen with the two-drug combination of cisplatin and vindesine, and toxic effects are similar. Thus, the addition of doxorubicin and/or cyclophosphamide adds no advantage to the use of the cisplatin and vindesine combination alone.
74例非小细胞肺癌患者参与了一项前瞻性随机试验,分别接受顺铂、阿霉素、环磷酰胺和长春地辛四药联合方案(PACE)或顺铂、环磷酰胺和长春地辛三药联合方案(PCE)治疗。这些患者均未接受过先前的化疗,且卡诺夫斯基体能状态均至少为60。在68例可评估患者中,21例(31%)获得完全或部分缓解。PACE和PCE的缓解率相似,腺癌或鳞癌患者的缓解率无差异。缓解的中位持续时间为10个月(范围2 - 26 +);5例患者仍处于缓解状态(中位时间18 +个月;范围17 +至26 +)。缓解患者(完全或部分缓解)的中位生存时间为18个月。总体而言,包括轻度至中度骨髓抑制、周围神经病变和肾毒性在内的毒性作用是可控的。PACE和PCE的缓解率及缓解持续时间与顺铂和长春地辛两药联合方案相似,毒性作用也相似。因此,添加阿霉素和/或环磷酰胺并不会给单独使用顺铂和长春地辛联合方案带来优势。