Budden M G
J Int Med Res. 1982;10(1):15-21. doi: 10.1177/030006058201000103.
a multicentre general practice study was undertaken to compare the efficacy of two proprietary dithranol preparations, Psoradrate 0.1% and Dithrocream 0.1%, in the treatment of chronic psoriasis, using a single blind, within-patient trial design. A total of forty-nine patients entered the study and treatment lasted for 6 weeks. Psoradrate 0.1% produced a greater mean per cent clinical improvement in psoriasis than Dithrocream 0.1% at each stage of the trial, and this difference was statistically significant (p equal to 0.025) at 4 weeks. The evidence also suggested that Psoradrate 0.1% resulted in greater reductions in psoriatic scaling. most patients found that the Psoradrate 0.1% was more effective and a significant majority (p equal to 0.01) thought that it worked faster than Dithrocream 0.1%. Although the increased effectiveness of the Psoradrate 0.1% was associated with a higher incidence of stinging/burning of the skin, this was not reflected in the patients' overall opinions of the treatments. Twenty-three patients preferred Psoradrate as against seventeen who preferred Dithrocream.
开展了一项多中心全科医疗研究,采用单盲、患者自身对照试验设计,比较两种专利蒽林制剂(0.1% 蒽林乳膏和0.1% 地蒽酚乳膏)治疗慢性银屑病的疗效。共有49名患者进入研究,治疗持续6周。在试验的每个阶段,0.1% 蒽林乳膏治疗银屑病的平均临床改善百分比均高于0.1% 地蒽酚乳膏,且在4周时这种差异具有统计学意义(p = 0.025)。证据还表明,0.1% 蒽林乳膏能更有效地减少银屑病鳞屑。大多数患者发现0.1% 蒽林乳膏更有效,并且绝大多数患者(p = 0.01)认为它比0.1% 地蒽酚乳膏起效更快。虽然0.1% 蒽林乳膏有效性的提高与皮肤刺痛/灼烧发生率较高有关,但这并未反映在患者对治疗的总体评价中。23名患者更喜欢蒽林乳膏,而17名患者更喜欢地蒽酚乳膏。