Dillon H
Ear Hear. 1982 Mar-Apr;3(2):51-8. doi: 10.1097/00003446-198203000-00001.
Several sources of variability inherent in any speech discrimination measurement are outlined. Limitations of the use of the binomial theorem to predict intrasubject (test-retest) variability are examined. First, the underestimation of variability that is caused by the inclusion of items of different degrees of difficulty is quantified by a reanalysis of published data. Second, it is shown that variability will be larger than expected if the subject's ability is different during test and retest sessions. Fortuitously, these two deviations from the model have opposing effects on the score variability. The estimates provided by the binomial theorem are thus better than if only one effect was present. The need for a clear distinction to be maintained between inter- and intra-subject variability and the effect of list differences on test-retest variability are also discussed.
概述了任何言语辨别测量中固有的几个变异性来源。研究了使用二项式定理预测受试者内部(重测)变异性的局限性。首先,通过对已发表数据的重新分析,量化了因纳入不同难度项目而导致的变异性低估。其次,研究表明,如果在测试和重测期间受试者的能力不同,变异性将大于预期。幸运的是,这两个与模型的偏差对分数变异性有相反的影响。因此,二项式定理提供的估计比仅存在一种影响时要好。还讨论了在受试者间和受试者内变异性之间保持明确区分的必要性,以及列表差异对重测变异性的影响。