Quabbe H J
Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 1982 Feb;16(2):107-19. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2265.1982.tb03154.x.
Two hundred and thirty patients with acromegaly were diagnosed and treated in a prospective cooperative study in twelve university clinics. Primary treatment was: trans-sphenoidal surgery (152 patients), trans-sphenoidal surgery with additional cryotherapy (eighteen patients), Yttrium-90-implantation (thirty patients), bromocriptine (thirty patients). The results of endocrine assessment before treatment and 6 months after operation, 90-Y implantation or commencement of bromocriptine therapy are reported. The best results (low GH, no or little deterioration of pituitary function, low complication rate) were achieved by trans-sphenoidal surgery, especially in patients with intrasellar tumours (basal GH less than 5 ng/ml in 59.7%). Results were less good with increasing tumour size. Additional cryosurgery was accompanied by a high rate of anterior pituitary insufficiency and is no longer employed. Yttrium-90-implantation resulted in less improvement in GH levels (basal GH less than 5 ng/ml in 51.7% of patients with intrasellar tumours), a high rate of pituitary insufficiency and more complications. Bromocriptine treatment was least effective in lowering GH concentrations (basal GH less than 5 ng/ml in 33% of patients with intrasellar tumours). Different criteria for treatment success were compared. In the entire group, basal GH concentrations below 5 ng/ml were attained in 51.7% of all patients whose values were higher than this prior to treatment. Suppressibility of GH below 2 ng/ml during glucose loading occurred in only 34.9%. An abnormal GH response to TRH/LHRH was present in 47.2% before and in 43.4% after/during treatment. The prognostic significance of this latter finding must be evaluated by further study.
在一项由十二家大学诊所参与的前瞻性合作研究中,对230例肢端肥大症患者进行了诊断和治疗。主要治疗方法包括:经蝶窦手术(152例患者)、经蝶窦手术联合额外冷冻治疗(18例患者)、钇-90植入(30例患者)、溴隐亭治疗(30例患者)。报告了治疗前以及手术、90-Y植入或溴隐亭治疗开始后6个月时的内分泌评估结果。经蝶窦手术取得了最佳效果(生长激素水平低、垂体功能无恶化或轻微恶化、并发症发生率低),尤其是对于鞍内肿瘤患者(59.7%的患者基础生长激素水平低于5 ng/ml)。随着肿瘤尺寸增大,效果变差。额外的冷冻手术伴随着较高的垂体前叶功能减退发生率,现已不再使用。钇-90植入导致生长激素水平改善较少(鞍内肿瘤患者中51.7%的患者基础生长激素水平低于5 ng/ml),垂体功能减退发生率高且并发症更多。溴隐亭治疗在降低生长激素浓度方面效果最差(鞍内肿瘤患者中33%的患者基础生长激素水平低于5 ng/ml)。比较了不同的治疗成功标准。在整个研究组中,治疗前生长激素水平高于5 ng/ml的所有患者中,51.7%的患者治疗后基础生长激素浓度低于5 ng/ml。葡萄糖负荷试验期间生长激素抑制至2 ng/ml以下的情况仅发生在34.9%的患者中。治疗前47.2%的患者以及治疗后/治疗期间43.4%的患者存在生长激素对促甲状腺激素释放激素/促黄体生成素释放激素的异常反应。后一发现的预后意义必须通过进一步研究来评估。