Albery E H, Bennett J A, Pigott R W, Simmons R M
Br J Plast Surg. 1982 Apr;35(2):118-26. doi: 10.1016/0007-1226(82)90147-3.
Of one hundred patients with velopharyngeal incompetence subjected to a pharyngoplasty selected on the results of endoscopic and radiological examination 97% were cured of unacceptable nasal escape and 93% of unacceptable nasal resonance on the criteria described. It was considered that this provided a vindication of the system of treatment. Critical examination of the morbidity revealed an unacceptably high proportion of hyponasality. This appeared to be due to ignoring the criteria for selection for pharyngoplasty and opting for the more radical operation resulting in over-treatment in some cases. With the numbers available in the smaller treatment groups it was not possible to state that there was no significant difference in the results between the different pharyngoplasties in the groups for which they were selected. It is expected that there will be a larger proportion of patients receiving less radical treatment without detriment to the success rate, but with a lower morbidity. Assuming that it is accepted that as much accurate information as possible prior to operation is needed for the correct selection of operation, simultaneous endoscopic and radiological examination provide a time- and cost-efficient system the benefit of which becomes overwhelming for revision of the failed pharyngoplasty.
在内镜和放射学检查结果基础上选择的100例接受咽成形术治疗的腭咽闭合不全患者中,按照所描述的标准,97%的患者不可接受的鼻腔漏气得到治愈,93%的患者不可接受的鼻腔共鸣得到治愈。这被认为是对该治疗体系的一种证明。对并发症的严格检查发现,鼻音减退的比例高得令人无法接受。这似乎是由于忽视了咽成形术的选择标准,而选择了更激进的手术,导致在某些情况下治疗过度。鉴于较小治疗组中的可用病例数量,无法表明所选组中不同咽成形术的结果之间没有显著差异。预计将有更大比例的患者接受不太激进的治疗,而不会损害成功率,但并发症发生率会更低。假设人们接受在手术前需要尽可能多的准确信息以正确选择手术,那么同步进行的内镜和放射学检查提供了一种节省时间和成本的体系,对于失败的咽成形术的修复而言,其益处变得极为显著。