Allodi F
Can J Psychiatry. 1982 Aug;27(5):366-73. doi: 10.1177/070674378202700503.
The syndrome of acute paranoid reaction is studied within the Canadian context. The main purpose of the study is to clarify its nosology and diagnostic criteria so that its diagnosis becomes more reliable and true epidemiological rates may be established. The historical development of the concept is briefly outlined in a review of the world literature, with particular attention being paid to its defining characteristics. The differential diagnosis with schizophrenia and paranoid states is of great importance given the different prognosis and treatment. Evidence from the literature is presented to show the role of sociocultural factors in the causation and diagnosis of this syndrome. Canadian data of first admissions to mental hospitals with diagnoses of reactive psychosis, including acute paranoid reaction type, for the years 1969-1973, in selected provinces, are presented. Rates of reactive psychoses as proportions of all admissions and all admission psychoses are compared with rates available for other European and Third World countries. Canadian national rates are lower and it is argued that the lower incidence is partly attributable to misdiagnosis which in turn is due to psychiatric training and to the neglect of the role attributed to sociocultural factors in the genesis of this condition.
急性偏执反应综合征是在加拿大的背景下进行研究的。该研究的主要目的是阐明其疾病分类学和诊断标准,以便使其诊断更加可靠,并能够确定真实的流行病学发病率。在对世界文献的综述中简要概述了该概念的历史发展,特别关注其定义特征。鉴于预后和治疗方法不同,与精神分裂症和偏执状态的鉴别诊断至关重要。文中呈现了文献证据,以表明社会文化因素在该综合征病因及诊断中的作用。列出了1969 - 1973年加拿大选定省份首次因诊断为反应性精神病(包括急性偏执反应型)而入住精神病院的数据。将反应性精神病占所有入院病例及所有入院精神病病例的比例与其他欧洲和第三世界国家的可用数据进行了比较。加拿大的全国发病率较低,有人认为发病率较低部分归因于误诊,而误诊又归因于精神病学培训以及对社会文化因素在该疾病发生过程中所起作用的忽视。