Wells S A, Baylin S B, Johnsrude I S, Harrington D P, Mendelsohn G, Ontjes D J, Cooper C W
Ann Surg. 1982 Nov;196(5):505-11. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198211000-00001.
In kindreds with familial medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), individuals are often detected whose peripheral plasma calcitonin (CT) levels are undetectable in the basal state but increase minimally following provocative testing. The proper management of such patients has been uncertain, but most investigators have advocated repeat testing and evaluation after an interval of several months. The present study was conducted to evaluate the diagnostic implications of these modest increases in plasma calcitonin. In 25 kindred members at direct risk for familial medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), basal peripheral plasma calcitonin (CT) levels were less than 240 pg/ml. Following provocative testing with intravenous calcium or pentagastrin or both, calcitonin values remained below 240 pg/ml in eight subjects (Group A), however, they were mildly elevated (260-580 pg/ml) in 12 subjects (Group B) and moderately elevated (700-940 pg/ml) in five subjects (Group C). Following the transfemoral placement of a catheter into the inferior thyroid vein (ITV), provocative testing was repeated, and ITV and peripheral blood samples were collected simultaneously. Basal ITV plasma CT levels were below 240 pg/ml in all patients in Group A, however, they were mildly elevated (500 pg/ml) in one of the 12 patients in Group B and moderately elevated (800 pg/ml, 1400 pg/ml) in two of the five patients in Group C. Following provocation, ITV plasma CT levels became markedly elevated in one patient in Group A and in all of the patients in Groups B(2520+/-635 pg/ml) and C (6322+/-2598 pg/ml). Thyroidectomy was performed in patients whose ITV plasma CT level was elevated following provocative testing. Medullary thyroid carcinoma of C-cell hyperplasia were evident either on microscopic (1/1 patient in Group A;9/12 patients in Group B; and 2/5 patients in Group C), or gross (3/12 patients in Group B;3/5 patients in Group C) examination of thyroidectomy specimens. In only one of 14 patients was metastatic MTC noted on histologic examination of resected cervical lymph nodes. Postoperative peripheral plasma CT levels were unchanged from basal and less than 240 pg/ml following provocative testing in all but one patient. The present study then provides definitive evidence that patients at direct risk for familial MTC who have even minimally abnormal responses in peripheral plasma CT following provocative testing generally harbor some stage of a C-cell proliferative disorder. Identification of such individuals with early disease is important because thyroidectomy offers an extremely high cure rate.
在患有家族性甲状腺髓样癌(MTC)的家族中,常可检测到一些个体,其基础状态下外周血浆降钙素(CT)水平检测不到,但激发试验后仅略有升高。这类患者的恰当管理一直不明确,但大多数研究者主张在数月间隔后进行重复检测和评估。本研究旨在评估血浆降钙素这些轻微升高的诊断意义。在25名有家族性甲状腺髓样癌(MTC)直接风险的家族成员中,基础外周血浆降钙素(CT)水平低于240 pg/ml。经静脉注射钙剂或五肽胃泌素或两者进行激发试验后,8名受试者(A组)的降钙素值仍低于240 pg/ml,然而,12名受试者(B组)的降钙素值轻度升高(260 - 580 pg/ml),5名受试者(C组)的降钙素值中度升高(700 - 940 pg/ml)。经股动脉将导管置入甲状腺下静脉(ITV)后,重复激发试验,并同时采集ITV和外周血样本。A组所有患者的基础ITV血浆CT水平均低于240 pg/ml,然而,B组12名患者中的1名患者的ITV血浆CT水平轻度升高(500 pg/ml),C组5名患者中的2名患者的ITV血浆CT水平中度升高(800 pg/ml,1400 pg/ml)。激发试验后,A组1名患者以及B组(2520±635 pg/ml)和C组(6322±2598 pg/ml)所有患者的ITV血浆CT水平显著升高。对激发试验后ITV血浆CT水平升高的患者进行了甲状腺切除术。在甲状腺切除标本的显微镜检查(A组1/1例患者;B组9/12例患者;C组2/5例患者)或大体检查(B组3/12例患者;C组3/5例患者)中均发现了C细胞增生性甲状腺髓样癌。在切除的颈部淋巴结的组织学检查中,仅14例患者中的1例发现有转移性MTC。除1例患者外,所有患者术后外周血浆CT水平与基础水平无变化,激发试验后低于240 pg/ml。本研究进而提供了确凿证据,即有家族性MTC直接风险的患者,即使在激发试验后外周血浆CT有极其轻微的异常反应,通常也处于C细胞增殖性疾病的某个阶段。识别这类早期疾病患者很重要,因为甲状腺切除术可提供极高的治愈率。