Cuarón A, Acero A, Cárdenas M
Arch Inst Cardiol Mex. 1982 Sep-Oct;52(5):365-72.
Myocardial scintigraphy with 99mTc-Sn (II)-Methylenediphosphonate (MDP) and with 99mTc-Sn (II) pyrophosphate (PPi) was performed in 185 patients with proven acute myocardial infarction (90 with MDP; 95 with PPi), and in 65 subjects with acute chest pain of a different etiology (37 with MDP; 28 with PPi), during the first five days after the onset of illness. Sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of the procedure were higher with PPi (0.895, 0.893, 0.894) than with MDP (0.822, 0.865, 0.835) in the diagnosis of AMI. Based on the usual clinical electrocardiographic and biochemical criteria, the likelihood of AMI on the population studied with MDP was of 70.9% and with PPi of 77.2%. Application of Bayes' theorem showed an increase in the likelihood of AMI, when myocardial scintigraphy was positive, from 70.9% to 93.7% when MDP was used, and from 77.2% to 96.6 when PPi was the tracer, with incremental ruling in gaings of 22.8% and 19.4%) respectively. A normal scintigraphy, on the other hand, reduced the likelihood of AMI from 70.9% to 33.4% when MDP was used, and from 77.2% to 29.2% when PPi was the tracer, with respective incremental ruling-out gains of 37.5% and 48.0%. Although homogeinity between the populations studied with each tracer was not proven, existing practical, clinical and biochemical evidence allows the conclusion that PPi is a better agent than MDP in the study of patients with acute chest pain.
在185例经证实的急性心肌梗死患者(90例使用亚甲基二膦酸盐[MDP];95例使用焦磷酸盐[PPi])以及65例病因不同的急性胸痛患者(37例使用MDP;28例使用PPi)发病后的头五天内,进行了99m锝-锡(II)-亚甲基二膦酸盐(MDP)和99m锝-锡(II)焦磷酸盐(PPi)心肌闪烁扫描。在急性心肌梗死(AMI)的诊断中,PPi检查的敏感性、特异性和准确性(分别为0.895、0.893、0.894)高于MDP(分别为0.822、0.865、0.835)。根据常规临床心电图和生化标准,使用MDP研究的人群中AMI的可能性为70.9%,使用PPi的为77.2%。贝叶斯定理的应用表明,当心肌闪烁扫描呈阳性时,使用MDP时AMI的可能性从70.9%增加到93.7%,使用PPi作为示踪剂时从77.2%增加到96.6%,分别有22.8%和19.4%的递增确诊收益。另一方面,正常的闪烁扫描结果使使用MDP时AMI的可能性从70.9%降至33.4%,使用PPi作为示踪剂时从77.2%降至29.2%,分别有37.5%和48.0%的递增排除收益。尽管未证实使用每种示踪剂研究的人群之间具有同质性,但现有的实践、临床和生化证据表明,在急性胸痛患者的研究中,PPi是比MDP更好的药物。