Selzer M A
Psychiatry. 1981 Feb;44(1):60-8. doi: 10.1080/00332747.1981.11024092.
THE case conference is a staple of academic life in psychiatry. Ostensibly, it provides the teaching hospital with a forum for considering issues of diagnosis, treatment, and interview technique. On an inpatient service, the case conference also holds the potential for uncovering the covert dynamics at work in the treatment setting; it is the task of the consultant who leads the conference to see that this potential is met. A major part of the consultant's work is bringing to life the hidden agendas of the conference. These hidden agendas are usually unconscious needs or wishes of the staff which are played out in relation to the consultant. Staff members attempt to influence the consultant to fulfill one of three basic wishes: the wish that the consultant ally himself with a certain faction; the wish that he sanction a position that has already been adopted; the wish that he expose or punish those whom the staff members are afraid to confront directly. These agendas provide the key to identifying central conflicts which obstruct therapeutic work. Although most often these conflicts appear between staff and patient, they also arise among staff members as well as between the unit staff and the hospital administration. This paper will examine examples of the dynamics of these hidden agendas and show how they reflect the influence which the patient has on the staff.
病例讨论会是精神病学学术生活的一项主要内容。表面上,它为教学医院提供了一个讨论诊断、治疗和访谈技巧问题的论坛。在住院部,病例讨论会还有可能揭示治疗环境中潜在的隐秘动态;主持会议的会诊医生的任务就是确保这种可能性得以实现。会诊医生工作的一个主要部分就是使会议隐藏的议程变得鲜活起来。这些隐藏的议程通常是工作人员无意识的需求或愿望,它们会在与会诊医生的关系中展现出来。工作人员试图影响会诊医生以满足三种基本愿望之一:希望会诊医生与某个特定派别结盟;希望他认可已采取的立场;希望他揭露或惩罚那些工作人员不敢直接面对的人。这些议程为识别阻碍治疗工作的核心冲突提供了关键。虽然这些冲突最常出现在工作人员与患者之间,但也会在工作人员之间以及科室工作人员与医院管理层之间出现。本文将审视这些隐藏议程动态的例子,并展示它们如何反映患者对工作人员的影响。