Draper H H, Scythes C A
Fed Proc. 1981 Jul;40(9):2434-8.
Gross epidemiological data indicate there are no significant differences in rates of aging osteopenia among countries with substantially different amounts of Ca in their national food supplies. This-observation, plus the fact that Ca administration fails to reverse osteoporotic bone loss, has led some investigators to conclude that Ca nutrition is an insignificant factor in the etiology of osteoporosis. However, it has become apparent that a Ca intake that may be adequate for adults consuming a low protein, low P, neural, or alkaline cereal-based diet is not necessarily adequate for subjects consuming a high protein, high P, acidic mixed Western diet. Ca administration inhibits postmenopausal osteopenia and there is epidemiological evidence that a liberal Ca intake reduces bone loss in middle adulthood. Ca intakes in the United States and Canada appear generally satisfactory among children and young adults, but low intakes by many individuals of middle age is a cause for concern, especially among women. Although the Ca:P ratio for the average diet consumed in these countries (about 1:1.6) appears to be satisfactory, a low intake of dairy foods, coupled with a high intake of other foods rich in natural and added phosphorus, may raise the ratio above 1:2, a value beyond which animal studies indicate that there is a risk of increased bone loss.
总体流行病学数据表明,在国家食物供应中钙含量存在显著差异的国家之间,老年性骨质减少的发生率并无显著差异。这一观察结果,再加上补钙未能逆转骨质疏松性骨质流失这一事实,使得一些研究人员得出结论,即钙营养在骨质疏松症的病因中是一个无关紧要的因素。然而,显而易见的是,对于食用低蛋白、低磷、素食或碱性谷类食物的成年人来说足够的钙摄入量,对于食用高蛋白、高磷、酸性混合西式饮食的人来说不一定足够。补钙可抑制绝经后骨质减少,并且有流行病学证据表明,充足的钙摄入量可减少中年时期的骨质流失。美国和加拿大儿童及年轻人的钙摄入量总体上似乎令人满意,但许多中年人钙摄入量较低令人担忧,尤其是女性。尽管这些国家平均饮食中的钙磷比(约为1:1.6)似乎令人满意,但乳制品摄入量低,再加上其他富含天然磷和添加磷的食物摄入量高,可能会使该比例升至1:2以上,动物研究表明,超过这一数值就存在骨质流失增加的风险。