Trowbridge F L, Staehling N
Am J Clin Nutr. 1980 Mar;33(3):687-96. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/33.3.687.
Arm circumference indicators of nutritional status such as simple arm circumference, arm circumference-for-age and arm circumference-for-height have advantages for field use because of their simplicity and low cost. However, these indicators need to be evaluated in terms of their ability to identify children who are manourished by more accepted criteria such as weight-for-age and weight-for-height. This study used sensitivity-specificity analysis to evaluate arm circumference indicators in 3838 children 1 to 4 years of age in a rural area of El Salvador. It was found that simple arm circumference gave sensitivity-specificity results similar to arm circumference-for-age and generally better than arm circumference-for-height in identifying children with low weight-for-age. The three arm circumference indicators gave similar sensitivity-specificity results in identifying children with low weight-for-height. Linear correlations of the arm circumference indicators with weight-for-age and weight-for-height gave results which correspond to the results of sensitivity-specificity analysis, but the information obtained from correlations to was less useful in evaluating the adequacy of the individual arm circumference indicators for screening purposes. Sensitivity-specificity analysis is proposed as useful method for evaluating indicators for use in nutritional surveys and for screening for malnutrition.
诸如上臂围、年龄别上臂围和身高别上臂围等营养状况的上臂围指标,因其简单易行且成本低廉,在现场应用中具有优势。然而,这些指标需要根据其识别营养不良儿童的能力进行评估,评估标准采用更为公认的年龄别体重和身高别体重等指标。本研究采用敏感度-特异度分析,对萨尔瓦多农村地区3838名1至4岁儿童的上臂围指标进行评估。结果发现,在识别年龄别体重低的儿童方面,单纯上臂围得出的敏感度-特异度结果与年龄别上臂围相似,且总体上优于身高别上臂围。在识别身高别体重低的儿童方面,这三种上臂围指标得出的敏感度-特异度结果相似。上臂围指标与年龄别体重和身高别体重的线性相关性得出的结果与敏感度-特异度分析结果相符,但从相关性中获得的信息在评估各个上臂围指标用于筛查目的的充分性方面用处较小。敏感度-特异度分析被提议作为评估营养调查中使用的指标以及筛查营养不良的有用方法。