Brown J E, O'Shea J S
Pediatrics. 1980 Mar;65(3):575-8.
In an attempt to identify methods of improving interviewing skills, 14 pediatric medical students (group 1) were randomly assigned to receive feedback concerning an audiovisually taped interview and to participate in a didactic session on interviewing skills. Seventeen students (group 2) had feedback sessions only, and 31 (group 3) had neither feedback nor didactic sessions. Each student was taped while interviewing a simulated mother both before and after receiving the assigned input. Group 1 improved more than group 3 in organizational abilities and more than either group 2 or group 3 in obtaining histories of present illnesses. Improvements in rapport, organization and information eliciting abilities were correlated with the amount of time taken for the interviews. Differences observed between the three groups in the pre-input interviews, which were carried out within several days of the students' becoming aware of their group assignments, stress the need of obtaining pre-input evaluations routinely in assessing medical education techniques.
为了确定提高问诊技巧的方法,14名儿科医学生(第1组)被随机分配接受关于一次视听录像问诊的反馈,并参加一次关于问诊技巧的教学课程。17名学生(第2组)仅参加反馈课程,31名学生(第3组)既不参加反馈课程也不参加教学课程。在接受指定的培训之前和之后,每个学生在对一名模拟母亲进行问诊时都被录像。第1组在组织能力方面比第3组提高得更多,在获取现病史方面比第2组或第3组提高得更多。融洽关系、组织能力和信息获取能力的提高与问诊所花费的时间有关。在学生得知自己被分配到的小组后的几天内进行的培训前问诊中,三组之间观察到的差异强调了在评估医学教育技术时常规获取培训前评估的必要性。