Taavitsainen M, Järvinen H, Standertskjöld-Nordenstam C G, Tallroth K
Ann Chir Gynaecol. 1978;67(4):154-60.
The diagnostic yields of intravenous cholangiography (IVC) and 99mTc-diethyl-IDA cholescintigraphy (CS) were compared in 50 patients; 19 had acute cholecystitis, 5 pancreatitis, 4 obstructive disease of the common bile duct, 5 chronic gallbladder disease, 6 parenchymal liver disease and 11 had other intra-abdominal diseases. The comparison of IVC and CS covered three aspects: the definition of the biliary tract structures, their morphologic changes and an assessment of bile flow through the cystic duct and the common bile duct. The definition of the main intrahepatic bile ducts was better with IVC; that of the common bile duct and the gallbladder was better with CS. Morphologic details such as calculi or local changes in duct calibre were detected only in IVC. Measurements of common bile duct calibre obtained from operative cholangiograms correlated better with those from the IVCs than with those from the CSs. CS was more sensitive in the diagnosis of cystic duct obstruction. Bile flow in the common bile duct was estimated in the cases where the gallbladder did not fill. Delayed emptying of the common bile duct was revealed in IVC in 1 and in CS in 3 out of 6 cases with disturbed bile flow. The morphologic findings in IVC gave indication of the obstructive condition in the 1 case with retarded flow and in 2 additional cases. CS provided functional information for which the concentration of the tracer was sufficient except in one case. IVC provided morphologic and functional information, but the excretion of the contrast medium was insufficient for a morphologic assessment of the common bile duct in 16 cases and for a functional assessment in 11 cases.
对50例患者的静脉胆管造影(IVC)和99mTc - 二乙基亚氨基二乙酸胆管闪烁造影(CS)的诊断效果进行了比较。其中19例患有急性胆囊炎,5例患有胰腺炎,4例患有胆总管梗阻性疾病,5例患有慢性胆囊疾病,6例患有实质性肝脏疾病,11例患有其他腹腔内疾病。IVC和CS的比较涵盖三个方面:胆道结构的界定、其形态学变化以及对通过胆囊管和胆总管的胆汁流动的评估。IVC对肝内主要胆管的界定更佳;CS对胆总管和胆囊的界定更佳。仅在IVC中检测到了诸如结石或导管管径局部变化等形态学细节。手术胆管造影获得的胆总管管径测量值与IVC测量值的相关性优于与CS测量值的相关性。CS在诊断胆囊管梗阻方面更敏感。在胆囊未显影的病例中评估了胆总管内的胆汁流动。在6例胆汁流动异常的病例中,1例IVC显示胆总管排空延迟,3例CS显示胆总管排空延迟。IVC的形态学发现提示了1例胆汁流动延迟病例以及另外2例病例的梗阻情况。除1例病例外,CS提供了示踪剂浓度足够的功能信息。IVC提供了形态学和功能信息,但造影剂的排泄在16例病例中不足以对胆总管进行形态学评估,在11例病例中不足以进行功能评估。