Stevenson H W, Parker T, Wilkinson A, Bonnevaux B, Gonzalez M
Monogr Soc Res Child Dev. 1978;43(3):1-92.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the influence of schooling and general environmental conditions on the development of memory and cognitive skills in young children. The subjects were 824 5- and 6-year-old children living in jungle villages and in slum settlements of Lima, Peru. Half of the children in both the jungle and city were Mestizo, and half were Quechua Indians. Some 6-year-olds of each cultural group and in each location attended school; others did not. Memory tasks were presented in different modes of representation, that is, verbal, pictorial, and enactive; and cognitive tasks in "concrete" and "abstract" versions. A sample of parents in each group was interviewed concerning environmental conditions. In addition, samples of upper-middle-class children in Lima and poor children in Detroit were tested to assess the generality of the findings. Attendance at school was related to improvement in performance on all tasks. Improvement was equivalent for both locations, both cultural groups, and each social class. Attendance at school also was accompanied by reduced within-group variability on some tasks and by greater differentiation of cognitive processes within children. Location and cultural group interacted differentially by task according to a complex pattern of relations. There were no indications that the organization of memory or cognitive processes differed as a function of social class, age, location, or cultural group. The results were interpreted in terms of children's opportunities to acquire specific memory and cognitive skills from schooling and from their general experience in a particular environment.
本研究的目的是调查学校教育和一般环境条件对幼儿记忆和认知技能发展的影响。研究对象是824名居住在秘鲁利马丛林村庄和贫民窟的5岁和6岁儿童。丛林和城市中的儿童各有一半是梅斯蒂索人,另一半是克丘亚印第安人。每个文化群体和每个地点的一些6岁儿童上学,另一些则不上学。记忆任务以不同的表征方式呈现,即言语、图像和动作表征;认知任务则有“具体”和“抽象”两种版本。对每个组的一部分家长就环境条件进行了访谈。此外,还对利马上层中产阶级儿童样本和底特律贫困儿童样本进行了测试,以评估研究结果的普遍性。上学与所有任务的表现改善有关。两个地点、两个文化群体和每个社会阶层的改善情况相当。上学还伴随着某些任务中组内变异性的降低以及儿童认知过程的更大分化。根据复杂的关系模式,地点和文化群体在不同任务上存在差异交互作用。没有迹象表明记忆或认知过程的组织因社会阶层、年龄、地点或文化群体而有所不同。研究结果是根据儿童从学校教育和特定环境中的一般经历中获得特定记忆和认知技能的机会来解释的。