Stone K S, Scholten D J, Dean R E
Am Surg. 1980 Aug;46(8):444-8.
The accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity of ultrasound versus oral cholecystography (OCG) in the preoperative diagnosis of gallstones was studied in 144 patients undergoing cholecystectomy. The 89 per cent accuracy of ultrasound was similar to the 92 per cent achieved with OCG. However, ultrasound was found to have a lower false-positive rate and a greater sensitivity with far fewer indeterminate studies than OCG. A high rate of nonvisualization diminished the usefulness of OCG as a first-line test. Because of a greater sensitivity less tendency for false-positive results, and a moninvasive nature, ultrasound should be the initial diagnostic study of choice in patients with suspected gallstones.
对144例接受胆囊切除术的患者进行了研究,以比较超声检查与口服胆囊造影术(OCG)在术前诊断胆结石方面的准确性、敏感性和特异性。超声检查89%的准确率与口服胆囊造影术92%的准确率相似。然而,研究发现超声检查的假阳性率较低,敏感性更高,不确定检查的数量也远少于口服胆囊造影术。较高的不显影率降低了口服胆囊造影术作为一线检查的实用性。由于超声检查具有更高的敏感性、更低的假阳性结果倾向以及无创性,对于疑似胆结石的患者,超声检查应作为首选的初始诊断方法。