Callies A L, Popkin M K, Mackenzie T B, Mitchell J
Am J Psychiatry. 1980 Oct;137(10):1250-3. doi: 10.1176/ajp.137.10.1250.
In an attempt to characterize consultees' representations of consultants' psychiatric dagnoses, the authors reviewd the medical records from 190 psychiatric consultations in a general hopsital. Using specific outcome criteria, they rated 50% of representations as concordant and 39% as nonconcordant. Five variable,s icluding the primary medical diagnosis at discharge and the referring service, were significantly related to concordance. Surprisinlgy, concordance was independent of the psychiatric diagnosis, indicating theat consultees did not respond differentially to varying magnitudes and implications of the different disorders. This work raises the question of possible strategies to improve receptivity to psychiatric diagnoses in the consultation setting.
为了描述会诊者对会诊医生精神科诊断的理解,作者回顾了一家综合医院190次精神科会诊的病历。使用特定的结果标准,他们将50%的理解评定为一致,39%为不一致。五个变量,包括出院时的主要医学诊断和转诊科室,与一致性显著相关。令人惊讶的是,一致性与精神科诊断无关,这表明会诊者对不同疾病的不同严重程度和影响没有不同反应。这项工作提出了在会诊环境中提高对精神科诊断接受度的可能策略的问题。