Eibach H, Börger U
Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 1980;226(3):177-86. doi: 10.1007/BF00455132.
The prime aim of this study is to investigate the influence of therapeutic measures in acute acoustic trauma (AAT). In a controlled clinical trial 209 patients (Table 1) was observed, starting within 2 days after the traumatic event. Various chemical agents, considered to have some influence on microciculation and metabolism of the inner ear, were administered as shown in Table 2. The control group was treated with NaCl infusions and glucose tablets. Statistical analysis of the audiometric data was performed in two different ways (Fig. 2). First, variations of absolute pure tone thresholds were studied in a regression analysis, revealing a close dependency of absolute hearing gains upon pretherapeutic hearing losses. Significant differences of permanent threshold shifts between test and control group could not be observed. Secondly, distribution curves of relative hearing gains (Figs. 1 and 2) were compared using the Kruskal Wallis test. The hypothesis of all of these curves being part of the same sample could not be rejected (P = 0.01). Thus, it was concluded that the four different forms of polypragmatic therapy used in this trial do not exert an effect on AAT exceeding that of NaCl infusions and glucose tablets. Under the assumption of a placebo effect of NaCl infusions and glucose tablets, either the supply with oxygen and neurotrop vitamins is no limiting factor in the regeneration process of the organ of Corti after an AAT, or the administered drugs fail to influence this supply. The effect of hospitalization with consequent reduction of noise and emotional stress was not studied in this paper.
本研究的主要目的是调查急性声创伤(AAT)治疗措施的影响。在一项对照临床试验中,观察了209例患者(表1),从创伤事件发生后2天内开始。如表2所示,给予了各种被认为对内耳微循环和代谢有一定影响的化学药物。对照组接受氯化钠输液和葡萄糖片治疗。对听力测定数据进行了两种不同方式的统计分析(图2)。首先,在回归分析中研究了绝对纯音阈值的变化,发现绝对听力增益与治疗前听力损失密切相关。未观察到试验组和对照组之间永久性阈值偏移的显著差异。其次,使用Kruskal Wallis检验比较了相对听力增益的分布曲线(图1和图2)。所有这些曲线是同一样本一部分的假设不能被拒绝(P = 0.01)。因此,得出结论,本试验中使用的四种不同形式的综合治疗对AAT的影响并不超过氯化钠输液和葡萄糖片。在假设氯化钠输液和葡萄糖片有安慰剂效应的情况下,要么氧气和神经营养维生素的供应在AAT后柯蒂氏器再生过程中不是限制因素,要么所给药未能影响这种供应。本文未研究住院导致的噪音和情绪压力降低的影响。