Rouzioux J M, Lery N
Anesth Analg (Paris). 1980;37(9-10):599-603.
After having looked at which was the value and the scientific extent of experiments on a healthy man, the authors show in which conditions this type of experiment can be considered as ethical. Two points are important in order to admit this ethical character: the necessity of the experiment and the existence of a collective benefit. Then, the juridical outline of these experiments is debated and the authors remind: --that medicinal products are experimented on the healthy man, --that there are texts which make official the acts offering risk, with collective benefit exclusively, --that a law imposes experiments for non-medicinal products. Finally, the types of responsibilities which could be looked at in case of experiment on a healthy man, with collective benefit, are debated.
在审视了对健康人进行实验的价值和科学程度之后,作者们指出了在哪些条件下这类实验可被视为符合伦理道德。为了认可这种伦理特性,有两点很重要:实验的必要性和集体利益的存在。接着,对这些实验的法律框架进行了讨论,作者们提醒道:——药品是在健康人身上进行实验的;——有一些文本使仅具有集体利益的冒险行为合法化;——有一项法律规定了非药品的实验。最后,讨论了在对健康人进行具有集体利益的实验时可能涉及的责任类型。