Röthlisberger C, Meier B
Cardiology, University Hospital, Bern, Switzerland.
Eur Heart J. 1995 Jul;16(7):922-9. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.eurheartj.a061026.
The general practice of coronary interventions is influenced by various aspects, traditional, cultural, socioeconomic and personal. The aim of this survey was to collect the data on coronary intervention in all member countries of the European Society of Cardiology. The data from 12 of the 35 national members were missing or grossly incomplete and were therefore excluded from the analysis.
The total number of coronary angiograms was reported as 683,888, an incidence of 1009 +/- 1021 per million inhabitants (range 9 (Romania) to 3076 (Germany)). Germany (246,115 cases), France (144,754), the United Kingdom (76,296), Italy (45,517) and Spain (43,495) registered 81% of all the coronary angiograms performed.
(PTCA) The total number of reported PTCAs was 147,729, which on average accounted for 19 +/- 11% (range 2 (Lithuania) to 53% (Netherlands)) of the coronary angiograms. Most of the PTCAs (82%) were confined to a single vessel. The highest incidence of multivessel PTCA was reported from Slovakia (28%). PTCA took place immediately after the diagnostic study in only 18% of cases. Adjusted per capita, Germany ranked first with 703 PTCAs per million inhabitants, followed by Iceland (619), France (614), Belgium (568) and Austria (485). A major in-hospital complication was reported in 2.5% of the patients undergoing PTCA: 0.4% hospital deaths, 1.0% emergency CABGs and 1.1% myocardial infarctions.
Stents were implanted in 3211 patients (2.7% of all PTCA patients), equally distributed between emergency situations (53%) and elective procedures. Other interventional devices were applied in 4133 cases (2.8% of all PTCA cases): directional atherectomy, rotablator, transluminal extraction catheter, laser and Rotacs accounted for 1452, 1232, 55, 558 and 222, respectively. Coronary ultrasound (1350 cases) and coronary angioscopy (373 cases) were rarely performed.
CORONARY ARTERY BYPASS GRAFTING (CABG): A total of 63,477 patients underwent CABG in the reporting centres resulting in a PTCA/CABG ratio of 2.3. A significant under-reporting of surgery in the participating centres must be assumed.
Although partial reporting might bias conclusions, several findings of this survey are noteworthy: (1) PTCA was a well accepted treatment for coronary artery disease, (2) PTCA was applied more frequently than CABG, (3) there was an extremely wide range of coronary angiography and PTCA performed per million inhabitants, (4) the most common additional procedure was stent implantation, but other new devices were only rarely applied.
冠状动脉介入治疗的一般实践受到传统、文化、社会经济和个人等多方面因素的影响。本次调查的目的是收集欧洲心脏病学会所有成员国冠状动脉介入治疗的数据。35个国家成员中有12个的数据缺失或严重不完整,因此被排除在分析之外。
报告的冠状动脉造影总数为683,888例,发病率为每百万居民1009±1021例(范围从9例(罗马尼亚)到3076例(德国))。德国(246,115例)、法国(144,754例)、英国(76,296例)、意大利(45,517例)和西班牙(43,495例)进行的冠状动脉造影占所有造影的81%。
经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术(PTCA):报告的PTCA总数为147,729例,平均占冠状动脉造影的19±11%(范围从2%(立陶宛)到53%(荷兰))。大多数PTCA(82%)局限于单支血管。斯洛伐克报告的多支血管PTCA发病率最高(28%)。仅18%的病例在诊断性研究后立即进行PTCA。按人均调整后,德国以每百万居民703例PTCA位居第一,其次是冰岛(619例)、法国(614例)、比利时(568例)和奥地利(485例)。2.5%接受PTCA的患者报告发生了主要的院内并发症:0.4%的医院死亡、1.0%的急诊冠状动脉搭桥术和1.1%的心肌梗死。
3211例患者植入了支架(占所有PTCA患者的2.7%),在急诊情况(53%)和择期手术中分布均匀。其他介入器械应用于4133例(占所有PTCA病例的2.8%):定向旋切术、旋磨术、腔内血栓抽吸导管、激光和Rotacs分别占1452例、1232例、55例、558例和222例。冠状动脉超声(1350例)和冠状动脉血管镜检查(373例)很少进行。
冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG):报告中心共有63,477例患者接受了CABG,PTCA/CABG比率为2.3。必须假定参与中心的手术报告存在严重漏报情况。
尽管部分报告可能会使结论产生偏差,但本次调查的几个结果值得关注:(1)PTCA是治疗冠状动脉疾病广泛接受的方法;(2)PTCA的应用比CABG更频繁;(3)每百万居民进行的冠状动脉造影和PTCA数量范围极大;(4)最常见的附加手术是支架植入,但其他新器械很少应用。