Nozaki D, Nakazawa K, Yamamoto Y
Laboratory for Exercise Physiology and Biomechanics, Graduate School of Education, University of Tokyo, Japan.
Exp Brain Res. 1995;105(3):402-10. doi: 10.1007/BF00233040.
The amplitude of the H-reflex has been known to have considerable variability even if the intensity of the stimulation is held constant. However, previous studies largely ignored the time-dependent profile of this variability. Recent mathematical analyses have shown that some seemingly irregular biological signals have fractal properties. A fractal time series is characterized by the property of self-similarity (self-affinity), and has long-range time correlation. The aim of this study was to investigate the question of whether the fluctuation of H-reflex was fractal with strong time-correlation. Soleus H-reflexes were evoked in five healthy subjects at two levels of stimulation intensity [1.2 MT (motor threshold) and 0.9 MT] every 1 s and 1050 successive amplitudes of H-wave and M-wave were recorded twice. The sequences of the H-wave and the M-wave amplitudes were analyzed by "coarse graining spectral analysis" to calculate the percentage of random fractal components in the sequences (%Fractal) and the spectral exponent beta. The %Fractal values of both sequences were above 90% [H-wave: 93.3 +/- 2.3% (1.2 MT), 91.6 +/- 3.1% (0.9 MT); M-wave: 94.3 +/- 3.3%; mean +/- SD]. Nonflat power spectra of the fractal components were observed for the H-wave sequences regardless of the stimulation intensity [beta = 0.75 +/- 0.26 (1.2 MT), 0.80 +/- 0.39 (0.9 MT)], indicating that the sequences were strongly time correlated. On the other hand, the M-wave sequences had a flatter spectrum (beta = 0.26 +/- 0.14) which was close to uncorrelated white noise. These results indicated that: (1) the fractal correlation found in the H-wave sequences was caused neither by the conduction through nerve fibers nor by the transmission at the neuromuscular junction, because the M-wave sequence had a significantly weaker time correlation, and (2) antidromic impulses in a motor nerve induced by the stimulation made a minor contribution to the generation of fractal correlation in the H-wave sequences, because it was preserved when the stimulation intensity was below MT. It was suggested that the fractal correlation in human H-reflex was generated at the synaptic connections to alpha-motoneurons in the spinal cord.
已知即使刺激强度保持恒定,H反射的波幅仍具有相当大的变异性。然而,以往的研究在很大程度上忽略了这种变异性的时间依赖性特征。最近的数学分析表明,一些看似不规则的生物信号具有分形特性。分形时间序列的特征是自相似性(自仿射性),并且具有长程时间相关性。本研究的目的是探讨H反射的波动是否具有强时间相关性的分形特征。在五名健康受试者中,以两种刺激强度水平[1.2MT(运动阈值)和0.9MT]每隔1秒诱发比目鱼肌H反射,并记录1050个连续的H波和M波波幅,共记录两次。通过“粗粒化频谱分析”对H波和M波波幅序列进行分析,以计算序列中随机分形成分的百分比(%分形)和频谱指数β。两个序列的%分形值均高于90%[H波:93.3±2.3%(1.2MT),91.6±3.1%(0.9MT);M波:94.3±3.3%;平均值±标准差]。无论刺激强度如何,H波序列的分形成分均观察到非平坦功率谱[β = 0.75±0.26(1.2MT),0.80±0.39(0.9MT)],表明序列具有强时间相关性。另一方面,M波序列的频谱更平坦(β = 0.26±0.14),接近不相关的白噪声。这些结果表明:(1)H波序列中发现的分形相关性既不是由神经纤维传导引起的,也不是由神经肌肉接头处的传递引起的,因为M波序列的时间相关性明显较弱;(2)刺激诱发的运动神经中的逆向冲动对H波序列中分形相关性的产生贡献较小,因为当刺激强度低于运动阈值时,这种相关性仍然存在。提示人体H反射中的分形相关性是在脊髓中与α运动神经元的突触连接处产生的。