Marks D A, Kim J, Spencer D D, Spencer S S
Department of Neurosciences, UMDNJ-New Jersey Medical School, Newark 07103, USA.
Neurology. 1995 Nov;45(11):2051-7. doi: 10.1212/wnl.45.11.2051.
We studied seizure localization and surgical pathology in 25 patients who developed intractable complex partial seizures following head trauma. All patients underwent an extensive presurgical evaluation that included MRI, neuropsychological evaluation, and surface EEG monitoring, and 21 had intracranial EEG monitoring. Seizures were successfully localized in nine patients; all nine underwent a surgical procedure and are seizure-free. Six of these patients had a mesial temporal lobe seizure focus, of whom five had a pathologic diagnosis of mesial temporal sclerosis. All five patients who developed mesial temporal sclerosis sustained their head injury at or before age 5 years. The three remaining patients whose seizures were successfully localized had neocortical foci and circumscribed radiographic abnormalities, which were presumed to be secondary to head trauma, and all had successful surgical resections of the epileptogenic focus. The remaining 16 patients sustained later trauma, and all had successful surgical resections of the epileptogenic focus. The remaining 16 patients sustained later trauma and did not have a focal MRI lesion, and their seizures were not adequately localized. We conclude that as a group, seizure foci secondary to head trauma are difficult to localize accurately, and this should deter surgical intervention. There was an association between early head injury (ie, at or before age 5 years) and mesial temporal sclerosis, and this association aided seizure localization and successful surgical intervention. Therefore, under the right circumstances, trauma can be a suitable historical element in the profile of patients in whom epilepsy surgery is successful.
我们研究了25例头部外伤后发生难治性复杂部分性发作患者的癫痫灶定位及手术病理情况。所有患者均接受了全面的术前评估,包括磁共振成像(MRI)、神经心理学评估及头皮脑电图监测,其中21例进行了颅内脑电图监测。9例患者的癫痫发作成功定位;这9例均接受了手术治疗,术后无癫痫发作。其中6例患者有内侧颞叶癫痫灶,5例病理诊断为内侧颞叶硬化。所有5例发生内侧颞叶硬化的患者在5岁及以前曾受过头部外伤。其余3例癫痫发作成功定位的患者有新皮质病灶及局限性影像学异常,推测与头部外伤有关,均成功切除了致痫灶。其余16例患者后来受过外伤,均成功切除了致痫灶。其余16例患者后来受过外伤且MRI无局灶性病变,其癫痫发作未能充分定位。我们得出结论,作为一个群体,头部外伤继发的癫痫灶难以准确定位,这应阻止手术干预。早期头部外伤(即5岁及以前)与内侧颞叶硬化之间存在关联,这种关联有助于癫痫灶定位及成功的手术干预。因此,在适当情况下,外伤可以作为癫痫手术成功患者病例中的一个合适的病史因素。