Scherer U, Büll U, Rothe R, Eisenburg J, Schildberg F W, Meister P, Lissner J
Eur J Nucl Med. 1978 Apr 1;3(2):71-80. doi: 10.1007/BF00251627.
This study was performed to comparatively assess the diagnostic accuracy of computerized tomography (CT) and nuclear liver-scanning in detecting and defining circumscript and diffuse liver diseases in 83 patients. Presence or absence of liver diseases was assessed based on the results of invasive diagnostic procedures such as biopsy, laparoscopy, laparotomy, and/or autopsy. The percentage of true negative diagnoses was 94% for CT and 91% for static gamma-imaging (n = 33). With a rate of 94% true positive diagnoses, CT proved to be superior to gamma imaging with radiocolloids (81% true positives) in diagnosing circumscript liver diseases (n = 31). In addition. CT was superior to nuclear imaging regarding discrimination of number and size of space-occupying lesions within the liver. In contrast to nuclear screening, CT scans were pathognomonic to some circumscript liver diseases such as cysts, metastases, and perhaps echinococciasis. This was also true for obstructive jaundice. Nuclear imaging, because it reflects a sort of liver function, was superior with cirrhosis, whereas CT showed only alterations in the size and shape of the liver and spleen.
本研究旨在比较计算机断层扫描(CT)和核素肝脏扫描对83例患者局限性和弥漫性肝脏疾病的诊断准确性。根据活检、腹腔镜检查、剖腹手术和/或尸检等侵入性诊断程序的结果评估是否存在肝脏疾病。CT的真阴性诊断率为94%,静态γ显像为91%(n = 33)。在诊断局限性肝脏疾病(n = 31)时,CT的真阳性诊断率为94%,在这方面被证明优于放射性胶体γ显像(真阳性率81%)。此外,在区分肝脏内占位性病变的数量和大小时,CT优于核素显像。与核素筛查不同,CT扫描对某些局限性肝脏疾病如囊肿、转移瘤以及可能的棘球蚴病具有特征性表现。梗阻性黄疸也是如此。核素显像由于反映某种肝功能,在肝硬化方面表现更优,而CT仅显示肝脏和脾脏大小及形状的改变。