Kiers L, Clouston P, Zuniga G, Cros D
Clinical Neurophysiology Laboratories, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114.
Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol. 1994 Aug;93(4):255-64. doi: 10.1016/0168-5597(94)90027-2.
We examined F wave mean and minimum latency, mean and maximum amplitude, duration, persistence and chronodispersion in 241 nerves from 78 patients with Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) and 162 nerves from 43 patients with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP). Results were compared with normal criteria derived from 72 median, 73 ulnar and 73 tibial control nerves, to determine the relative diagnostic sensitivity of the various F wave parameters. F wave abnormalities were found in 92% and 95% of nerves of patients with GBS and CIDP respectively. Absence of F responses or prolongation of minimum and mean latency were the most frequent abnormalities in both groups. Forty-five (11.2%) nerves overall had absent F responses with normal compound muscle action potential (CMAP) amplitudes and no significant fall between stimulus sites, consistent with isolated proximal conduction block. Forty-four nerves (23.7% of nerves in which F waves were present) fulfilled minimum F latency criteria for acquired demyelination . Eighty-one (20.1%) nerves had normal conventional motor nerve conduction studies and abnormal F responses, not all of which were identified by assessing only F absence or minimum latency. Severity of F wave abnormalities did not correlate with clinical outcome. Our findings confirm the high frequency of proximal nerve lesions in early GBS and CIDP, not all of which are associated with distal motor conduction abnormalities, and suggest that assessment of multiple F wave parameters, in particular chronodispersion, mean latency and mean amplitude (in addition to absence and minimum latency), increases the yield of F wave studies.
我们检测了78例吉兰-巴雷综合征(GBS)患者的241条神经以及43例慢性炎症性脱髓鞘性多发性神经病(CIDP)患者的162条神经的F波平均潜伏期和最小潜伏期、平均波幅和最大波幅、时限、出现率及离散度。将结果与来自72条正中神经、73条尺神经和73条胫神经的正常对照标准进行比较,以确定各种F波参数的相对诊断敏感性。GBS和CIDP患者的神经中分别有92%和95%出现F波异常。F反应缺失或最小潜伏期和平均潜伏期延长是两组中最常见的异常。总体上有45条神经(11.2%)F反应缺失,复合肌肉动作电位(CMAP)波幅正常,刺激部位之间无明显下降,符合孤立性近端传导阻滞。44条神经(F波存在的神经中的23.7%)符合获得性脱髓鞘的最小F潜伏期标准。81条神经(20.1%)常规运动神经传导研究正常但F反应异常,并非所有这些异常都通过仅评估F反应缺失或最小潜伏期来识别。F波异常的严重程度与临床结果无关。我们的研究结果证实了早期GBS和CIDP中近端神经病变的高发生率,并非所有这些病变都与远端运动传导异常相关,并表明评估多个F波参数,特别是离散度、平均潜伏期和平均波幅(除了缺失和最小潜伏期),可提高F波研究的阳性率。