Repair of critical size rat calvarial defects using extracellular matrix protein gels.

In this study the authors examined the capacity of gels of reconstituted basement membrane, laminin, and type I collagen to mediate repair of critical size defects in rat calvaria. Although autografts are widely used to repair bone defects caused by trauma or surgical treatment of congenital malformations, neoplasms, and infections, an adequate quantity of graft is not always available. Allogenic bone is readily available, but its use is associated with an increased incidence of nonunion, fatigue fracture, and rejection. Biologically active, purified components of basement membranes, which have been shown to promote osteogenic differentiation and angiogenesis in vitro and type I collagen (the major constituent of bone extracellular matrix) can be formed into native isotonic space-filling gels. In this study critical size calvarial defects were created in retired male Sprague-Dawley rats. Thirty-six animals were divided into seven groups. Group 1 (control) received no treatment for the defects. Group 2 animals were implanted with methylcellulose. Groups 3, 4, 5, and 6 were implanted with gels of type I collagen, reconstituted basement membrane, or laminin, respectively. The last group of three animals (Group 7) was implanted with 100 micrograms of type I collagen gels (identical to Group 3) and sacrificed at 20 weeks following a single CT scan to determine if complete healing could be obtained with this method given sufficient time. Except for rats in the type I collagen group that was evaluated by multiple computerized tomography (CT) scans biweekly from 2 to 12 weeks, bone repair was evaluated using CT at 12 weeks. Healing was quantified using three-dimensional reconstruction of CT. Following the final CT scan in each experimental group, animals were sacrificed, and a sample of tissues was evaluated by conventional histology. Animals treated with type I collagen gels showed 87.5% repair of the area of the defects at 12 weeks and 92.5% repair by 20 weeks. Increasing the gel volume 1.5 x accelerated complete repair to 3 months. Murine-reconstituted basement membrane and laminin gels induced 55.5% and 46.3% repair, respectively, at 3 months. In untreated control animals 7% repair of the area of the defects showed at 3 months. Histological analysis confirmed new bone formation in partial and completely healed defects. Bioengineered native collagen gels may have wide applicability for bone repair as an alternative bone graft material alone, in combination with autograft or marrow aspirate, or as a delivery system for osteogenic growth factors.