Choudhuri G, Agarwal D K, Negi T S
Department of Gastroenterology, Sanjay Gandhi Postgraduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, India.
J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 1995 May-Jun;10(3):241-5. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1746.1995.tb01087.x.
A quick and reliable method for estimating the proportion of constituents of a stone may be useful in determining the prevalence of chemical type of gallstones in different geographic areas or ethnic groups. Chemical and infrared spectroscopy estimation facilities are not commonly available in many parts of the world and visual inspection may not be reliable for scientific purposes. To investigate whether identification of microcrystalline solids in partially dissolved stone powder could accurately predict the chemical nature of the gallstone we undertook a blind study on 40 samples of gallstones and compared our results with those of visual inspection and quantitative infrared spectroscopy. There were 29 cholesterol stones (mean cholesterol 83.4 +/- 7.5%), six intermediate cholesterol stones (mean cholesterol 48.0 +/- 21.2%) and five pigment stones (mean cholesterol 14.3 +/- 4.3%) as determined by quantitative infrared spectroscopy. Microscopic examination of partially dissolved gallstone powder in ethanol correctly identified all 29 cholesterol gallstones (sensitivity 100%, specificity 92%), four of six intermediate cholesterol stones (sensitivity 67%, specificity 100%) and all five pigment stones (sensitivity 100%, specificity 97%). It also detected microspheroliths of calcium carbonate in 14 of 16 calcium carbonate containing gallstones (sensitivity 88%, specificity 100%). The chemical grouping of stones on the basis of microscopic examination was correct in 37 (93%) of 40 samples and was especially useful in identifying 'intermediate' cholesterol stones which cannot be recognized by visual inspection. Thus microscopic examination of powdered gallstones appears to be a simple and reliable method of determining gallstone composition.
一种快速可靠的估算结石成分比例的方法,可能有助于确定不同地理区域或种族群体中胆结石化学类型的流行情况。世界上许多地方通常没有化学和红外光谱估算设备,而目视检查出于科学目的可能并不可靠。为了研究部分溶解的结石粉末中微晶固体的鉴定能否准确预测胆结石的化学性质,我们对40份胆结石样本进行了一项盲法研究,并将我们的结果与目视检查和定量红外光谱的结果进行了比较。通过定量红外光谱测定,有29颗胆固醇结石(平均胆固醇含量83.4±7.5%)、6颗中间胆固醇结石(平均胆固醇含量48.0±21.2%)和5颗色素结石(平均胆固醇含量14.3±4.3%)。对乙醇中部分溶解的胆结石粉末进行显微镜检查,正确识别出了所有29颗胆固醇结石(敏感性100%,特异性92%)、6颗中间胆固醇结石中的4颗(敏感性67%,特异性100%)以及所有5颗色素结石(敏感性100%,特异性97%)。它还在16颗含碳酸钙的胆结石中的14颗中检测到了碳酸钙微球粒(敏感性88%,特异性100%)。基于显微镜检查对结石进行的化学分组在40个样本中的37个(93%)是正确的,在识别目视检查无法识别的“中间”胆固醇结石方面尤其有用。因此,胆结石粉末的显微镜检查似乎是一种简单可靠的确定胆结石成分的方法。