Poser C M
Department of Neurology, Harvard Medical School and Beth Israel Hospital, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
J Formos Med Assoc. 1995 Jun;94(6):300-8.
The single most important feature that determines the reliability of epidemiologic studies of multiple sclerosis (MS) is the use of well-defined, generally recognized diagnostic criteria. The long-accepted direct relationship between prevalence rates (PR) and latitude is no longer valid and has been replaced by the realization that genetic factors play an important role in the acquisition of the disease. The nature of environmental factors, which may be of more importance in influencing the clinical manifestations of the disease, remains obscure. Most potential risk factors that have been studied lack biologic plausibility. Biostatistical interpretation of epidemiologic data can only indicate possible causal relationships but cannot conclusively rule out their existence. Differences in PR among different ethnic groups in similar locations suggest that, in addition to genetic factors, there may be enhancing and/or protective influences which are probably environmental in nature. Migration studies have been interpreted as suggesting that MS is acquired before puberty and that age at migration is important in determining the risk of having clinical disease. Epidemics by age of onset vanish when recalculated on the basis of age of acquisition, and probably mean that more early and mild cases are being diagnosed. A new definition of PR is proposed, ie, onset-adjusted PR, which includes patients who had symptoms at the time of the survey, but had not yet been diagnosed as MS. However, individuals who had symptoms at the time of migration to a study area must not be included in PR.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
决定多发性硬化症(MS)流行病学研究可靠性的唯一最重要特征是使用明确界定、普遍认可的诊断标准。长期以来被认可的患病率(PR)与纬度之间的直接关系已不再成立,取而代之的是认识到遗传因素在该病的发病过程中起着重要作用。环境因素的性质在影响该病临床表现方面可能更为重要,但其仍然不明朗。大多数已研究的潜在风险因素缺乏生物学合理性。流行病学数据的生物统计学解释只能表明可能的因果关系,但不能确凿地排除其存在。在相似地点不同种族群体之间的PR差异表明,除了遗传因素外,可能还存在增强和/或保护作用,这些作用可能本质上是环境性的。迁移研究被解释为表明MS在青春期前发病,且迁移年龄在决定患临床疾病风险方面很重要。根据发病年龄重新计算时,按发病年龄划分的流行情况消失了,这可能意味着更多早期和轻症病例被诊断出来。提出了PR的一个新定义,即发病调整后的PR,其中包括在调查时已有症状但尚未被诊断为MS的患者。然而,在迁移到研究地区时已有症状的个体不得纳入PR。(摘要截短于250字)