Kesten S, Maidenberg A, Winton T, Maurer J
Toronto Lung Transplant Program, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1995 Oct;152(4 Pt 1):1321-4. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm.152.4.7551389.
The gold standard for the diagnosis and subsequent treatment of acute rejection of lung allografts is the demonstration of rejection on transbronchial biopsy specimens. However, treatment may be initiated in the case of a compatible clinical scenario in the absence of definitive histologic documentation. In the Toronto Lung Transplant Program, we have treated patients with a decline in FEV1 and no evidence of infection with augmented systemic steroids for a presumed diagnosis of rejection. We retrospectively reviewed all episodes of acute rejection that occurred beyond 6 mo after transplant where treatment with augmented steroids had been initiated. A total of 72 treatments with augmented steroids were initiated in 45 patients who underwent 47 transplant procedures. FEV1 showed at least a 10% improvement following steroids in 14 of 72 (19%). FEV1 continued to decline by at least 10% in 32 of 72 (44%). Changes in FEV1 between +10 and -10% occurred in 26 of 72 (36%); of those episodes, 19 showed a decline of < 10%. Histologic evidence of at least grade II rejection was documented in only 16 cases. In those cases, FEV1 improved by at least 10% in 7 of 16 (44%), whereas it declined by at least 10% in 4 of 16 (25%). Spirometric evidence of bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome developed within 3 mo of the treated rejection episode in at least 20 of 47 transplants (43%). We conclude that treatment with augmented systemic steroids for presumed and histologically proven acute rejection beyond 6 mo after transplant is often ineffective in improving spirometry.
肺移植急性排斥反应诊断及后续治疗的金标准是经支气管活检标本显示有排斥反应。然而,在缺乏明确组织学证据的情况下,若临床情况相符也可开始治疗。在多伦多肺移植项目中,对于预计诊断为排斥反应、FEV1下降且无感染证据的患者,我们使用增加剂量的全身类固醇进行治疗。我们回顾性分析了移植6个月后发生的所有急性排斥反应事件,这些事件均已开始使用增加剂量的类固醇进行治疗。共有45例患者接受了47次移植手术,共进行了72次增加剂量类固醇治疗。72例患者中,14例(19%)在使用类固醇后FEV1至少提高了10%。72例患者中,32例(44%)FEV1持续下降至少10%。72例患者中,26例(36%)FEV1变化在+10%至-10%之间;在这些病例中,19例下降幅度小于10%。只有16例有至少Ⅱ级排斥反应的组织学证据。在这些病例中,16例中有7例(44%)FEV1至少提高了10%,而16例中有4例(25%)FEV1下降至少10%。在至少47例移植中的20例(43%)中,在治疗排斥反应事件后的3个月内出现了闭塞性细支气管炎综合征的肺量计证据。我们得出结论,对于移植6个月后推测性和组织学证实的急性排斥反应,使用增加剂量的全身类固醇治疗通常无法有效改善肺量计指标。