Margolis H S, Coleman P J, Brown R E, Mast E E, Sheingold S H, Arevalo J A
Hepatitis Branch (A-33), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA 30333, USA.
JAMA. 1995 Oct 18;274(15):1201-8.
To evaluate the outcome of immunization strategies to prevent hepatitis B virus (HBV) transmission.
A decision model was used to determine the incremental effects of the following hepatitis B immunization strategies in a birth cohort receiving immunization services in the public sector: (1) prevention of perinatal HBV infection, (2) routine infant vaccination, or (3) routine adolescent vaccination.
Over the lifetime of the cohort, the reduction in infections and medical and work-loss costs of HBV-related liver disease were determined for each strategy and compared with the outcome without immunization.
Prevention of perinatal infection and routine infant vaccination would lower the 4.8% lifetime risk of HBV infection by at least 68%, compared with a 45% reduction for adolescent vaccination. From a societal perspective, each strategy was found to be cost saving, but was not cost saving with respect to direct medical costs. The estimated cost per year of life saved was $164 to prevent perinatal HBV infection, $1522 for infant vaccination, and $3730 for adolescent vaccination.
Routine vaccination of infants in successive birth cohorts to prevent HBV transmission is cost-effective over a wide range of assumptions. While economically less attractive than infant vaccination, adolescent vaccination could serve to protect those children who were not vaccinated as infants.
评估预防乙型肝炎病毒(HBV)传播的免疫策略效果。
采用决策模型来确定在公共部门接受免疫服务的出生队列中,以下乙型肝炎免疫策略的增量效果:(1)预防围产期HBV感染;(2)常规婴儿疫苗接种;(3)常规青少年疫苗接种。
在该队列的一生中,确定每种策略可减少的感染病例数以及HBV相关肝病的医疗和工作损失成本,并与未进行免疫的结局进行比较。
与青少年疫苗接种使HBV感染终生风险降低45%相比,预防围产期感染和常规婴儿疫苗接种可将4.8%的HBV感染终生风险至少降低68%。从社会角度来看,每种策略都具有成本效益,但就直接医疗成本而言并非具有成本效益。预防围产期HBV感染每年挽救每生命年的估计成本为164美元,婴儿疫苗接种为1522美元,青少年疫苗接种为3730美元。
在一系列出生队列中对婴儿进行常规疫苗接种以预防HBV传播,在广泛的假设条件下具有成本效益。虽然在经济上不如婴儿疫苗接种有吸引力,但青少年疫苗接种可为那些婴儿期未接种疫苗的儿童提供保护。