Mirvis D M, Chang C F, Hall C J, Zaar G T, Applegate W B
Department of Preventive Medicine, University of Tennessee, Memphis 38163, USA.
JAMA. 1995 Oct 18;274(15):1235-41. doi: 10.1001/jama.274.15.1235.
TennCare, the health care system reform plan implemented in Tennessee on January 1, 1994, was developed with the dual objectives of controlling the rapidly rising cost of the state's Medicaid program and extending health insurance coverage to most Tennesseans without access to employer-sponsored or other government-sponsored health insurance. Beneficiaries enroll in competing, state-chartered managed care organizations that are responsible for providing broad preventive, inpatient, and outpatient services and are reimbursed by the state on a capitation basis at a rate based on a statewide global budget for health care. The program initially proposed to enroll up to 1,775,000 citizens and was projected to result in a cumulative cost savings to Tennessee and the federal government of $7.2 billion by the end of the 5-year demonstration period. However, major start-up problems encountered by the state and by managed care organizations and limitations imposed by the government have significantly constrained these expectations. At the end of its first year, more than 1.2 million citizens were enrolled, but the program incurred a $99 million deficit. Managed care organizations and hospitals have reported major financial problems, and constituency groups--especially those representing physicians--have attempted to block the program. Our objective is to describe the design and rationale of TennCare and discuss key issues the plan continues to face that may affect its long-term success.
田纳西医疗保健计划于1994年1月1日在田纳西州实施,是一项医疗保健系统改革计划,其制定有双重目标:控制该州医疗补助计划迅速上涨的成本,并将医疗保险覆盖范围扩大到大多数无法获得雇主提供或其他政府提供的医疗保险的田纳西州居民。受益者加入相互竞争的、由州特许的管理式医疗组织,这些组织负责提供广泛的预防、住院和门诊服务,并由州政府按人头付费的方式,根据全州医疗保健总预算确定的费率进行报销。该计划最初提议招收多达177.5万名公民,预计到5年示范期结束时,田纳西州和联邦政府将累计节省72亿美元。然而,该州和管理式医疗组织遇到的重大启动问题以及政府施加的限制,严重限制了这些预期。在第一年年底,超过120万公民登记加入,但该计划出现了9900万美元的赤字。管理式医疗组织和医院报告了重大财务问题,选民团体——尤其是代表医生的团体——试图阻止该计划。我们旨在描述田纳西医疗保健计划的设计和基本原理,并讨论该计划持续面临的可能影响其长期成功的关键问题。