Hutt J M, Ludes B, Kaess B, Tracqui A, Mangin P
Clinique Dentaire, Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg, France.
Int J Legal Med. 1995;107(6):275-9. doi: 10.1007/BF01246872.
The authors report on the contribution of odontological identification of the flight AI. IT 5148 air disaster victims, which occurred on 20th January 1992. The identification procedure was difficult due to large numbers of bodies and mutilations and required the involvement of multidisciplinary teams composed of odontologists, forensic pathologists, radiologists and biologists. The authors set up a simple, discriminant classification which was easy to handle by a multidisciplinary team. Four groups were defined according to the matching characteristics between ante and post mortem data. Perfect matching characteristics between ante and post mortem data were achieved in only 44 cases (Group A). Partial matching characteristics between ante and post mortem data were achieved in 12 cases (Group B). In 29 cases, the insufficiency or absence of odontological data (Group C and D) did not enable the victim to be identified. The results of the investigations showed that the dental examination alone enabled 17 victims to be identified and by including a morphological examination the figure reached 33. By the end of the investigations, 85 of the 87 victims were positively identified. Odontological identification is an essential, accurate and rapid method with allows a body to be identified from its dental characteristics. This anthropometrical method of identification is included with the descriptive and the biological methods. The authors present their experience in performing a formal identification of 44 victims in less than 15 days.
作者报告了1992年1月20日发生的IT 5148航班空难遇难者的牙科学鉴定情况。由于尸体数量众多且残缺不全,鉴定过程困难重重,需要由牙科学家、法医病理学家、放射科医生和生物学家组成的多学科团队参与。作者建立了一种简单的判别分类方法,便于多学科团队操作。根据生前和死后数据的匹配特征定义了四组。生前和死后数据完全匹配的仅44例(A组)。生前和死后数据部分匹配的有12例(B组)。29例中,由于牙科学数据不足或缺失(C组和D组),无法确定受害者身份。调查结果显示,仅通过牙科检查就确定了17名受害者身份,加上形态学检查后这一数字达到33名。调查结束时,87名受害者中的85名得到了确切身份确认。牙科学鉴定是一种重要、准确且快速的方法,能够根据牙齿特征确定尸体身份。这种人体测量学鉴定方法与描述性和生物学方法一同使用。作者介绍了他们在不到15天的时间里对44名受害者进行正式身份鉴定的经验。