Andreasen N C, Winokur G
Am J Psychiatry. 1979 Jan;136(1):62-6. doi: 10.1176/ajp.136.1.62.
The authors evaluate the clinical and research significance of the diagnosis of secondary depression by comparing 48 cases of primary and 26 cases of secondary depression. The patients with secondary depression have a higher familial prevalence of alcoholism, affective disorder, and drug abuse. The groups differ somewhat on a few sociodemographic, behavioral, and attitudinal variables but are similar in symptomatology, sex ratio, onset and duration of symptoms, treatment received, and response to treatment. These results suggest that the distinction between primary and secondary depression should be retained in research that examines neurochemistry or genetics. Primary and secondary depression appear to be identical from the persepctive of clinical care. Management of these patients should emphasize the diagnosis of depression rather than antecedent diagnoses.
作者通过比较48例原发性抑郁症患者和26例继发性抑郁症患者,评估继发性抑郁症诊断的临床和研究意义。继发性抑郁症患者中,酒精中毒、情感障碍和药物滥用的家族患病率较高。两组在一些社会人口统计学、行为和态度变量上存在一定差异,但在症状学、性别比例、症状的发作和持续时间、接受的治疗以及对治疗的反应方面相似。这些结果表明,在研究神经化学或遗传学的研究中,应保留原发性和继发性抑郁症之间的区别。从临床护理的角度来看,原发性和继发性抑郁症似乎是相同的。对这些患者的管理应强调抑郁症的诊断,而不是先前的诊断。