Cooper D M, Dietz F R
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City 52242, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1995 Oct;77(10):1477-89. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199510000-00002.
We evaluated forty-five patients who had seventy-one congenital clubfeet. The average age was thirty-four years (range, twenty-five to forty-two years). Twenty-nine of these patients had been evaluated and reported on in 1980. We performed pedobarographic and electrogoniometric analyses in addition to the clinical and radiographic studies performed previously. With the use of pain and functional limitation as the outcome criteria, thirty-five (78 per cent) of the forty-five patients had an excellent or good outcome compared with eighty-two (85 per cent) of ninety-seven individuals who did not have congenital deformity of the foot. The patient's occupation, passive dorsiflexion as measured with a hand-held goniometer, the antero-posterior calcaneus-fifth metatarsal angle, the total foot pressure time integral, and the number of rapid single-limb toe-ups that could be performed were the only variables that differed significantly between the feet that had an excellent or good result and those that had a poor result (p < 0.05). A comparison of the feet that had an excellent or good outcome with those that had a poor outcome with regard to body-mass index, peak pressure under the heel, and force time integral under the metatarsal heads revealed a p value that was between 0.05 and 0.08 for each variable. The technique of treatment led to good long-term results in our patients who had clubfoot. The data suggest that a sedentary occupation and avoidance of excessive weight gain may improve the over-all long-term result. Excessive weakening of the triceps surae may predispose patients to a poor result; therefore, it is prudent to avoid overlengthening of this muscle. The outcome could not be predicted from the radiographic result.
我们评估了45例患有71只先天性马蹄内翻足的患者。平均年龄为34岁(范围为25至42岁)。其中29例患者在1980年已接受评估并被报道。除了之前进行的临床和放射学研究外,我们还进行了足压力分析和电子测角分析。以疼痛和功能受限作为结果标准,45例患者中有35例(78%)获得了优良结果,而97例无足部先天性畸形的个体中有82例(85%)获得了优良结果。患者的职业、用手持测角仪测量的被动背屈、跟骨-第五跖骨前后角、全足压力时间积分以及可进行的快速单肢踮脚尖次数是结果优良的足部与结果较差的足部之间仅有的显著不同的变量(p<0.05)。就体重指数、足跟下的峰值压力以及跖骨头下的力时间积分而言,将结果优良的足部与结果较差的足部进行比较,每个变量的p值在0.05至0.08之间。治疗技术在我们的马蹄内翻足患者中取得了良好的长期效果。数据表明,久坐的职业和避免体重过度增加可能会改善总体长期结果。小腿三头肌过度弱化可能使患者易于出现较差的结果;因此,谨慎的做法是避免该肌肉过度延长。无法根据放射学结果预测治疗结果。