Biyani A, Simison A J, Klenerman L
Department of Orthopaedics, Arrowe Park Hospital, Upton, Wirral, UK.
Acta Orthop Belg. 1995;61(2):83-91.
We retrospectively reviewed the radiographs of 255 patients with intertrochanteric fractures over a 2 year period. The incidence of osteoarthritis of the hip joint in these patients was 12.16%, which is less than that reported in the general population, and which confirms the protective effect of osteoarthritis against intertrochanteric fractures. Osteoarthritis was mild in 14, moderate in 19, and severe in 4 hips. Seventeen of the 33 patients had died or were too ill to attend a review clinic. The remaining 16 patients (18 hips) were followed up clinically and radiographically 1 to 5.5 years (mean 2.25 years) after internal fixation of the hip fracture. Three patients with severe osteoarthritis, who were waiting for a total hip replacement before the hip fracture occurred became asymptomatic. There was no significant clinical or radiographic progression of mild and moderate hip osteoarthritis in the remaining 13 patients (15 hips). Intertrochanteric fractures appear to have a beneficial "osteotomy-like" effect on hip osteoarthritis in symptomatic patients.
我们回顾性分析了255例转子间骨折患者在两年期间的X线片。这些患者髋关节骨关节炎的发生率为12.16%,低于一般人群的报道,这证实了骨关节炎对转子间骨折的保护作用。14个股骨头的骨关节炎为轻度,19个股骨头为中度,4个股骨头为重度。33例患者中有17例死亡或病情太重无法前往复诊门诊。其余16例患者(18个股骨头)在髋部骨折内固定术后1至5.5年(平均2.25年)接受了临床和X线随访。3例在髋部骨折发生前等待全髋关节置换的重度骨关节炎患者症状消失。其余13例患者(15个股骨头)的轻度和中度髋部骨关节炎在临床和X线方面均无显著进展。转子间骨折对有症状患者的髋部骨关节炎似乎具有有益的“截骨样”作用。