Andretta M, Ianniello A, Ostuni P A, Siniscalchi E, Cusatelli P, Todesco S
Clinica ORL, Università di Padova.
Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital. 1995 Feb;15(1):40-6.
Various sets of criteria have been suggested in order to establish a diagnosis of Sjögren's syndrome (SS) in as much as evaluation of the salivary component is highly controversial. Our study was aimed at investigating both sensitivity and specificity of labial salivary gland biopsy (LSGB), as well as at comparing this method with other diagnostic procedures commonly employed in SS. LSGB was performed in 182 patients (174 female and 8 male, mean age 51.2) with xerostomia, dry eyes, parotid swelling and/or serological abnormalities such as positive rheumatoid factors, antinuclear antibodies, leukopenia and hypergammaglobulinemia. Diagnosis of SS was made according to the criteria recently proposed by Vitali et al. (1993). Severity of histologic changes was graded according to the Chisholm and Mason scoring system. Bioptic samples were considered abnormal when at least one focus of mononuclear cells/4mm2 was observed. The following parameters were also assessed in each patient: questionnaire of symptoms, Saxon test, sialography, salivary dynamic scintiscan, Schirmer-I-test, rose Bengal score, ANA, anti-SSA/SSB antibodies and rheumatoid factors. According to the above diagnostic criteria, 108 out of 182 patients had SS, 90 primary and 18 secondary. For 74 there were not enough data for a definite diagnosis of SS. In 9 cases (4 with and 5 without SS) LSGB was excluded because no glandular tissue was found in the specimens. Among the remaining 173, Grades 3 or 4 were found in 74 patients (71.2%) with SS and only in 1 case (1.4%) without SS. LSGB showed a very high specificity (98.6%) and a rather good sensitivity (72.5%). However, biopsy was crucial for diagnosis in only 11 cases (14.6%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
由于唾液成分的评估存在很大争议,人们提出了各种标准来诊断干燥综合征(SS)。我们的研究旨在调查唇腺活检(LSGB)的敏感性和特异性,并将该方法与SS中常用的其他诊断程序进行比较。对182例有口干、眼干、腮腺肿大和/或血清学异常(如类风湿因子阳性、抗核抗体、白细胞减少和高球蛋白血症)的患者(174例女性,8例男性,平均年龄51.2岁)进行了LSGB。根据Vitali等人(1993年)最近提出的标准对SS进行诊断。根据Chisholm和Mason评分系统对组织学变化的严重程度进行分级。当观察到至少一个单核细胞灶/4mm²时,活检样本被认为异常。还对每位患者评估了以下参数:症状问卷、萨克森试验、唾液造影、唾液动态闪烁扫描、Schirmer-I试验、孟加拉玫瑰红评分、ANA、抗SSA/SSB抗体和类风湿因子。根据上述诊断标准,182例患者中有108例患有SS,90例为原发性,18例为继发性。74例患者没有足够的数据来明确诊断SS。9例患者(4例患有SS,5例未患有SS)因标本中未发现腺组织而排除LSGB。在其余173例中,74例SS患者(71.2%)发现3级或4级,而无SS的患者仅1例(1.4%)。LSGB显示出非常高的特异性(98.6%)和相当好的敏感性(72.5%)。然而,活检仅对11例(14.6%)的诊断至关重要。(摘要截断于250字)