Wagner P J, Phillips W, Radford M, Hornsby J L
Department of Family Medicine, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta, USA.
Arch Fam Med. 1995 Jul;4(7):594-9; discussion 599. doi: 10.1001/archfami.4.7.594.
To examine differences between frequent and infrequent users in decisions to seek medical care based on symptom type and duration of experience of the symptom.
Retrospective study.
University family practice clinic.
Fifty-eight of 130 patients returned the completed instruments, a response rate of 45%.
The following two instruments were used: the Intentions to Seek Care questionnaire, which measures intention to see a physician, self-treat, or use medications for 11 different symptoms after three time periods--1 day, 3 days, and 1 week of symptom duration--and the SF-36 Health Survey measure.
Initial analyses suggested that patients perceive three clusters of symptoms, which we have labeled as serious, mild, and psychological. Scale scores for these groups of symptoms yielded significant reliability and were used in subsequent analyses. Multivariate analysis of variance comparing source of care, symptom duration, and frequent vs infrequent user groups indicated that both user groups are more likely to seek care from physicians for symptoms that are serious. Analysis of mild and psychological symptoms yielded significant three-way interactions, with frequent users more likely than infrequent users to seek care from physicians at a 1-day duration. Such differences disappear by 7 days. Significantly lower scores were obtained on five of the eight SF-36 Health Survey dimensions for the infrequent users.
Frequent users are more likely than infrequent users to report that they would seek care for minor symptoms. Infrequent users tend to self-treat for 3 to 7 days, after which time physician advice is sought. Efforts to teach patients optimal timing of use for different symptoms may be an effective intervention.
根据症状类型和症状经历时长,研究频繁就医者与不频繁就医者在寻求医疗护理决策上的差异。
回顾性研究。
大学家庭医疗诊所。
130名患者中有58名返还了填好的问卷,回复率为45%。
使用了以下两种工具:寻求护理意向问卷,该问卷测量在症状持续1天、3天和1周这三个时间段后,针对11种不同症状看医生、自我治疗或使用药物的意向;以及SF-36健康调查量表。
初步分析表明,患者将症状分为三类,我们分别标记为严重症状、轻度症状和心理症状。这些症状组的量表得分具有显著的信度,并用于后续分析。对就医来源、症状持续时间以及频繁就医者与不频繁就医者群体进行的多变量方差分析表明,两个用户群体在出现严重症状时都更有可能寻求医生的治疗。对轻度症状和心理症状的分析产生了显著的三向交互作用,频繁就医者比不频繁就医者更有可能在症状出现1天时就寻求医生的治疗。到7天时,这种差异消失。不频繁就医者在SF-36健康调查的八个维度中的五个维度上得分显著更低。
与不频繁就医者相比,频繁就医者更有可能报告他们会因轻微症状而寻求治疗。不频繁就医者倾向于自我治疗3至7天,之后才寻求医生的建议。努力教导患者针对不同症状的最佳就医时机可能是一种有效的干预措施。