Trent R, Adams J, Jennings K, Rawles J
Medicines Assessment Research Unit, University of Aberdeen, Foresterhill, UK.
Int J Cardiol. 1995 Mar 24;49(1):33-7. doi: 10.1016/0167-5273(95)02271-w.
Our objective was to estimate the saving of life by thrombolysis and resuscitation in acute myocardial infarction (AMI) before and after hospital admission. We studied all 1516 patients admitted to a Scottish teaching hospital in 1990 and 1992 who had a final diagnosis of AMI, and 311 patients enrolled in the Grampian region early anistreplase trial (GREAT). Cardiac arrest occurred in 250/1516 (16%) hospital patients. Of these, 77 (31%) were discharged alive--a saving of 51 lives per thousand cases. 797 (53%) patients received thrombolysis, of whom 114 (14%) died. Assuming the same relative reduction in mortality as in the second international study of infarct survival (ISIS-2; 23%), 34 lives were saved by thrombolytic therapy, representing 22 lives per thousand cases. Of 311 patients in GREAT, 15 (5%) had prehospital cardiac arrest, with 7 patients surviving to discharge (48%)--a saving of 23 lives per thousand cases. Those patients given domiciliary thrombolysis had a one month mortality of 6.7% (11/163) compared with 12.2% (18/148) for those receiving hospital thrombolysis--a saving of 55 lives per thousand cases for prehospital thrombolysis. This is additional to 28 lives per thousand estimated for thrombolytic therapy in hospital, totalling 83 lives saved per thousand cases of AMI receiving thrombolytic therapy prehospital. In hospital, more lives were saved by resuscitation than by thrombolytic therapy, but this ratio was reversed in the period before hospital admission. These results emphasise the paramount importance of resuscitation in hospital, and the enhanced efficacy of thrombolysis when given at the earliest opportunity.
我们的目标是评估急性心肌梗死(AMI)患者在入院前后通过溶栓和复苏所挽救的生命数量。我们研究了1990年和1992年入住一家苏格兰教学医院且最终诊断为AMI的所有1516例患者,以及311例参加格兰扁地区早期阿尼普酶试验(GREAT)的患者。1516例住院患者中有250例(16%)发生心脏骤停。其中,77例(31%)存活出院——每千例患者挽救51条生命。797例(53%)患者接受了溶栓治疗,其中114例(14%)死亡。假设死亡率的相对降低幅度与第二项国际梗死存活研究(ISIS - 2;23%)相同,溶栓治疗挽救了34条生命,相当于每千例患者挽救22条生命。在GREAT研究的311例患者中,15例(5%)在院前发生心脏骤停,7例存活出院(48%)——每千例患者挽救23条生命。接受家庭溶栓治疗的患者1个月死亡率为6.7%(11/163),而接受医院溶栓治疗的患者死亡率为12.2%(18/148)——院前溶栓治疗每千例患者挽救55条生命。这是除了估计在医院进行溶栓治疗每千例挽救28条生命之外的,接受院前溶栓治疗的每千例AMI患者总共挽救83条生命。在医院,复苏挽救的生命比溶栓治疗更多,但在入院前阶段这一比例则相反。这些结果强调了医院内复苏的至关重要性,以及尽早进行溶栓治疗时增强的疗效。