Contradictory supranormal nuclear renographic differential renal function: fact or artifact?

We previously reported contradictory supranormal nuclear renographic differential renal function in cases of unilateral hydroureteronephrosis, in which the kidneys with hydroureteronephrosis paradoxically had a greater differential function than the contralateral normal mate, based on diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (DTPA) nuclear renography. To evaluate whether DTPA supranormal differential function represented true hyperfunction, patients with DTPA supranormal differential function were evaluated with dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) nuclear renography and the results were compared. A total of 16 patients with unilateral hydronephrosis was identified to have DTPA differential function of 53% or more. They were younger than age 1 year and had never undergone any urological surgery. In all 16 patients the DMSA differential function (mean 51.1%, range 42 to 57%) was lower than their own corresponding DTPA differential function (mean 58.3%, range 53 to 66%, p < 0.0001). In addition, the DMSA differential function was not significantly different from the intuitively anticipated mean of 50% (p = 0.48). The DTPA supranormal differential function identified in our patients was not corroborated by the DMSA differential function. With recent evidence that DMSA differential function may be a better predictor of outcome following relief of unilateral ureteral obstruction consideration should be given to using DMSA as a potentially more relevant method for differential function measurement in the setting of unilateral hydronephrosis. Conversely, until the potential deficiencies of DTPA are fully understood caution should be exercised in the interpretation of DTPA differential function in the setting of hydronephrosis.