Khajavi K, Comair Y G, Prayson R A, Wyllie E, Palmer J, Estes M L, Hahn J F
Department of Neurosurgery, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, OH 44195, USA.
Pediatr Neurosurg. 1995;22(4):181-8. doi: 10.1159/000120899.
Gangliogliomas are an increasingly recognized cause of epilepsy in children. Several studies have shown that early surgical treatment is beneficial, but controversy exists regarding the type of surgical treatment required for optimal seizure control and to prevent tumor recurrence. To address this issue, we performed a retrospective review of 15 children operated on at the Cleveland Clinic during a 7-year period with medically intractable epilepsy who were found to harbor a ganglioglioma during the course of their work-up. Nine patients with mostly nondominant hemisphere tumors underwent tumor resection without the use of electrocorticography to guide additional resection of epileptogenic foci, while 6 other patients with dominant hemisphere tumors had subdural electrode grids placed to extraoperatively map zones of ictal onset and eloquent areas. The extent of tumor resection was then correlated to seizure outcome and tumor recurrence. Of the 11 patients who received a gross total resection, 9 are seizure-free while 2 have a greater than 90% reduction in their seizure frequency (100% 'good' outcome). There was no tumor recurrence in this group. Of the 4 patients who underwent a subtotal tumor resection, 1 is seizure-free while 3 have persistent seizures (25% 'good' outcome). All patients in this group have stable disease on follow-up magnetic resonance imaging. In those patients who received subdural electrode grids, the extent of resection of the zones of ictal onset did not correlate with seizure outcome. The mean follow-up was 42 months. We conclude that complete tumor resection is the most important factor for optimal seizure control and to prevent tumor recurrence.
神经节胶质瘤是儿童癫痫越来越常见的病因。多项研究表明,早期手术治疗有益,但对于实现最佳癫痫控制和预防肿瘤复发所需的手术治疗类型仍存在争议。为解决这一问题,我们对克利夫兰诊所7年间接受手术的15例儿童进行了回顾性研究,这些儿童患有药物难治性癫痫,在检查过程中发现患有神经节胶质瘤。9例主要为非优势半球肿瘤的患者在未使用皮质脑电图指导进一步切除癫痫病灶的情况下接受了肿瘤切除术,而另外6例优势半球肿瘤患者放置了硬膜下电极栅,以在术中绘制发作起始区和功能区。然后将肿瘤切除范围与癫痫发作结果和肿瘤复发情况进行关联。在11例接受了肿瘤全切的患者中,9例无癫痫发作,2例癫痫发作频率降低超过90%(“良好”结果率为100%)。该组无肿瘤复发。在4例接受肿瘤次全切的患者中,1例无癫痫发作,3例仍有持续性癫痫发作(“良好”结果率为25%)。该组所有患者在随访磁共振成像中病情稳定。在那些接受硬膜下电极栅的患者中,发作起始区的切除范围与癫痫发作结果无关。平均随访时间为42个月。我们得出结论,完整的肿瘤切除是实现最佳癫痫控制和预防肿瘤复发的最重要因素。