Giani P, Avanzini F, Bagliani G, Galati A, Pucci P, Santoro E
Divisione di Cardiologia, Ospedale Bolognini, U.S.S.L. 30, Seriate, BG.
G Ital Cardiol. 1995 Jan;25(1):77-87.
The relationship between ventricular arrhythmias (VA) in the subacute phase of a myocardial infarction (MI) and subsequent major arrhythmic events, i.e. sustained ventricular tachycardia (SVT) and sudden death (SD), is well known. The importance of left ventricular dysfunction in the same context is also well established. The vast majority of the data in the literature come from the prefibrinolytic era and/or are derived from limited data bases.
MATERIALS, METHODS AND RESULTS: We examined the large, uniform GISSI-2 population of acute fibrinolysed myocardial infarctions in order to evaluate the significance and predictive power of VA detected by Holter monitoring during the subacute phase. Particular attention was paid to the occurrence of nonsustained ventricular tachycardias (NSVT) since their role is still uncertain, so it is hard to assess the utility of invasive measures such as programmed electrical stimulation (PES). Left ventricular function was evaluated by mono-, and two-dimensional echocardiography. Holter monitoring was available in 8,676 patients; a six-month follow-up, as regards mortality was completed in 8,552 patients (98.5%) and, as regards SVT incidence, in 7.713 (88.9%). During the follow-up 256 patients died (3%), 84 out of them suddenly (1%). Twenty-six [corrected] patients out of 7,713 (0.3%) experienced one or more SVT. The relationship between VA, left ventricular dysfunction and major arrhythmic events was evaluated by odds ratios (OR) and their confidence intervals (CI). Odds ratios for the combined end-point (SD and/or SVT) was 4.49 (CI 95% 2.69-7.51) if the Holter showed > 10 VEB/hour; 2.34 (CI 1.48-3.68) if couplets were present; 3.26 (1.52-6.99) if NSVT were present; 3.02 (2.02-4.50) if any complex ventricular arrhythmia was detected. Left ventricular disfunction seemed to exert a more powerful influence: OR 9.80 (CI 5.75-16.69) for SD and/or SVT. Any arrhythmic parameter had very low positive (< or = 3%) and very high (approximately 99%) negative predictive power. Multivariate analysis (Cox Model) including major prognostic factors confirmed the independent prognostic value of frequent VA (RR 2.75; 95% CI 1.58-4.79), couplets (RR 1.91; CI 1.28-2.86); complex VA (RR 2.02; CI 1.36-3.00). NSVT, after adjusting for the selected risk factors, was not independently associated with a worse prognosis.
Ventricular arrhythmias detected by Holter monitoring during the subacute phase of a MI still have prognostic significance for major arrhythmic events in the fibrinolytic era. The presence of NSVT triples the risk of SD and/or SVT in the six months after an acute MI, but loses any predictive power in a multivariate analysis. Only 6.6% of the patients showed one or more episodes of NSVT in the Holter recording. If the ongoing clinical trials, MUSTT and MADIT, will confirm the usefulness of PES in such patients, the benefit will be confirmed to a very small proportion of the patients at risk of specific diagnostic tests. The positive predictive power of VA is very low and it is therefore mandatory to add other non-invasive variables to the screening to identify the subgroups at greatest risk. On the other hand the very high (99%) negative predictive power of VA and left ventricular dysfunction enables us to identify a large population of infarcts with a negligible risk, who need no further sophisticated investigations. From the point of view of the cost/benefit evaluation this seems to be an outstanding result.
心肌梗死(MI)亚急性期室性心律失常(VA)与随后的主要心律失常事件,即持续性室性心动过速(SVT)和猝死(SD)之间的关系已广为人知。左心室功能障碍在同一背景下的重要性也已得到充分证实。文献中的绝大多数数据来自纤维蛋白溶解前时代和/或源自有限的数据库。
材料、方法和结果:我们研究了大规模、统一的急性纤维蛋白溶解型心肌梗死GISSI-2人群,以评估亚急性期动态心电图监测检测到的VA的意义和预测能力。特别关注了非持续性室性心动过速(NSVT)的发生情况,因为其作用仍不确定,因此难以评估诸如程控电刺激(PES)等侵入性措施的效用。通过单维和二维超声心动图评估左心室功能。8676例患者进行了动态心电图监测;8552例患者(98.5%)完成了关于死亡率的6个月随访,7713例患者(88.9%)完成了关于SVT发生率的随访。随访期间,256例患者死亡(3%),其中84例猝死(1%)。7713例患者中有26例(0.3%)发生了一次或多次SVT。通过比值比(OR)及其置信区间(CI)评估VA、左心室功能障碍与主要心律失常事件之间的关系。如果动态心电图显示每小时室性早搏(VEB)>10次,联合终点(SD和/或SVT)的比值比为4.49(95%CI 2.69 - 7.51);如果存在成对室性早搏,则为2.34(CI 1.48 - 3.68);如果存在NSVT,则为3.26(1.52 - 6.99);如果检测到任何复杂性室性心律失常,则为3.02(2.02 - 4.50)。左心室功能障碍似乎发挥了更强的影响:SD和/或SVT的OR为9.80(CI 5.75 - 16.69)。任何心律失常参数的阳性预测值都非常低(≤3%),阴性预测值非常高(约99%)。包括主要预后因素的多变量分析(Cox模型)证实了频发VA(RR 2.75;95%CI 1.58 - 4.79)、成对室性早搏(RR 1.91;CI 1.28 - 2.86)、复杂性VA(RR 2.02;CI 1.36 - 3.00)的独立预后价值。在调整选定的危险因素后,NSVT与更差的预后无独立相关性。
在纤维蛋白溶解时代,MI亚急性期动态心电图监测检测到的室性心律失常对主要心律失常事件仍具有预后意义。NSVT的存在使急性心肌梗死后6个月内SD和/或SVT的风险增加两倍,但在多变量分析中失去了任何预测能力。在动态心电图记录中,仅6.6%的患者出现了一次或多次NSVT发作。如果正在进行的临床试验MUSTT和MADIT证实PES对此类患者有用,受益的将只是有特定诊断检查风险的患者中的一小部分。VA的阳性预测能力非常低,因此在筛查中必须添加其他非侵入性变量以识别风险最高的亚组。另一方面,VA和左心室功能障碍非常高(99%)的阴性预测能力使我们能够识别出大量风险可忽略不计的梗死患者,他们无需进一步的复杂检查。从成本/效益评估的角度来看,这似乎是一个出色的结果。