Sheth D S, Healey J H, Sobel M, Lane J M, Marcove R C
Department of Surgery, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY 10021, USA.
J Hand Surg Am. 1995 May;20(3):432-40. doi: 10.1016/S0363-5023(05)80102-9.
We compared the outcome of patients with giant cell tumor of the distal radius treated by curettage/cryosurgery and en bloc resection, evaluating oncologic success, functional results, and complications. Thirty consecutive cases of giant cell tumor of the distal radius were treated at our institution between 1958 and 1988. Twenty-six patients were available for follow-up examination, with a minimum follow-up period of 3 years and median follow-up period of 9 years. Primary curettage/cryosurgery had a local recurrence in 3 of 12, and repeat curettage/cryosurgery achieved local control in in 16 of 18 primary and recurrent cases. The major complications in this group included skin necrosis, transient nerve palsies, and fragmentation with carpal collapse. An average of 60% of contralateral range of wrist motion was preserved. Ten patients underwent en bloc excision and arthrodesis for either primary or recurrent tumor; none developed local recurrence. The main complication in this group was failure of internal fixation and non-union at the graft-radius junction. Resultant strength and function were similar in both groups. Intralesional excision with adjunctive cryosurgery is an effective alternative to en bloc excision with the advantage of preserving the distal radius and wrist joint function, but with a notable complication rate. En bloc excision with arthrodesis is more suitable for extensive local disease with poor residual bone stock and as salvage for failed intralesional excision.
我们比较了采用刮除/冷冻手术和整块切除治疗桡骨远端骨巨细胞瘤患者的治疗结果,评估肿瘤学疗效、功能结果和并发症。1958年至1988年期间,我们机构连续治疗了30例桡骨远端骨巨细胞瘤患者。26例患者可供随访检查,最短随访期为3年,中位随访期为9年。初次刮除/冷冻手术的12例中有3例局部复发,再次刮除/冷冻手术在18例初次及复发病例中有16例实现了局部控制。该组的主要并发症包括皮肤坏死、短暂性神经麻痹以及骨折块分离伴腕关节塌陷。平均保留了对侧腕关节活动范围的60%。10例患者因原发性或复发性肿瘤接受了整块切除和关节融合术;无一例发生局部复发。该组的主要并发症是内固定失败和植骨-桡骨交界处不愈合。两组的最终强度和功能相似。病灶内切除联合冷冻手术是整块切除的一种有效替代方法,其优点是保留桡骨远端和腕关节功能,但并发症发生率较高。整块切除并关节融合术更适用于局部病变广泛、残余骨量差的情况,以及作为病灶内切除失败后的挽救措施。